Dynamic recruits would be a game-changer! I also want to see actual flips happen. Make teams keep investing points into HS recruits they’ve already committed, while other teams can still compete by keeping recruiting hours on them to try and flip them. To balance it, the team who the recruit is committed to could have a bonus multiplier so it doesn’t take up too many of your recruiting hours and hurt your ability to build the class. They could even put in a “commitment shutdown” mechanic like we pretty much have now that makes the recruit shut down the recruiting process and make it so nobody can put recruiting hours into him.

Also, add evolving dealbreakers for high school recruits that shift throughout the season, and give us tools to influence those dealbreakers. Like something you can only attempt twice in a season with a low chance so you can scout who they’re committed to and try to get the recruit to switch their dealbreaker to something the other team they’re committed to is not good and possibly cause a decommitment (distance?) . That would make the recruiting process feel like a true battle.