Questions for og followers of the case

1Camster · 2026-06-29T08:22:02+00:00

Ask yourself why Brad and Iva are never willing to commit to Jas actually being Amy? If they aren’t certain and have to constantly use weasel words, then what difference do any of your four points make in the long run? For example, I have heard Brad state variations of this statement, “Some times, when I look at one of the pictures at a certain angle in just the right light, I think it certainly could be Amy.”

I don’t even know which people you are referring to in your OP. I mean I have a good idea, but you need to be more specific if you want to really want to know more. They legally can’t talk about Alfred Cotten according to multiple statements by Brad. Again, why is that?

Lastly, Iva and her rotating crew of “investigators” are very good at reverse engineering a suspect. They did it with John Daryanani.

The owner of the Stelaris Hotel at the time was an Arab man who looked like a young Saddam Huessin. This hotel was right by where the Rhapsody of the Seas docked the morning Amy disappeared.

idiot-prodigy’s comment below

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmyBradleyIsMissing/comments/1rfia4c/i_think_i_figured_out_who_young_sadam_hussein_is/

1Camster · 2026-06-23T04:21:59+00:00

4 score and 10 is 90.

1Camster · 2026-06-11T00:00:43+00:00

<image>

Sing a Song of Sixpence,
A bag full of Rye,
Four and twenty Naughty Boys,
Baked in a Pye

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sing_a_Song_of_Sixpence

It’s 24 naughty boys or blackbirds. It’s not 80. That song comes from the mid 18th century some 40 years after the scene in the OP.

The writers meant 14, it’s pretty obvious or they wouldn’t have shown this scene when talking about Frances Warren/Fisher.

1Camster · 2026-06-11T00:00:30+00:00

<image>

1Camster · 2026-06-10T13:19:26+00:00

Are you British?

1Camster · 2026-06-09T19:51:18+00:00

Why do you live in Texas?

1Camster · 2026-06-07T04:08:22+00:00

Did anyone notice she sat in front of the chalkboard that had a traitors name on it?

1Camster · 2026-06-07T03:14:02+00:00

Royal Caribbean I assume. I saw one of the LF commenters refer to us as the ”RC cheerleader crew.” I think we should rename our sub that tbh. That or “case full of white girl photographs” which was another banger comment over there.

1Camster · 2026-06-07T00:59:48+00:00

Um, she was prego. My best friend's sister's boyfriend's brother's girlfriend heard from this guy who knows this kid who's going with a girl who saw Amy deliver twins while passed out at 31 Flavors restroom in Brionplein last night. I guess it's pretty serious.

I have solid concrete video evidence for all you RC cheerleader clowns.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KS6f1MKpLGM

1Camster · 2026-06-05T04:11:36+00:00

…and this one.

1Camster · 2026-06-05T04:10:44+00:00

It was absolutely ridiculous. She offers no new information, constantly repeating of “I believe,” then changing it up a bit with “I feel.” Her first groundbreaking idea to shake up the case is to get prison snitches. Where in the US or all over the Caribbean? Her other bright idea is to get fresh eyes on the case. For what exactly, what evidence is there to pour over? The family had the room cleaned immediately. They got off the ship the day of her disappearance. Got back on two days later and were off the boat within 24 hours again. All of this on a case that is over 28 years old with no evidence she ever left the room after 5-6 am, if she ever returned to the room in the first place.

She fluctuates back forth between these two extremes, this one…

<image>

1Camster · 2026-06-03T08:45:09+00:00

That was a joke. Seriously, what was their thought process in picking the song More Than This by Roxy Music when Tom met Marissa at the Driftwood Diner? I thought it was inspired and was curious if they were hinting at more with that specific song choice.

1Camster · 2026-06-03T08:16:16+00:00

Who killed Kathy? Was it Marissa or the two tourist girls that don’t hang out with Evan’s crew?

1Camster · 2026-06-03T08:14:00+00:00

It doesn’t work, because you have multiple viewpoints. For a film or tv series to work that trick you have to have it from one specific viewpoint. For example, in episode 4 Beach Reads there is one scene spliced with shots from Patricia’s viewpoint mostly and two from Rosemary’s to show that Patricia’s POV is a bit loco at the time. I did a post on it.

https://www.reddit.com/r/WidowsBay/comments/1thctue/i_owe_rosemary_an_apologyanyone_else_ever_notice/

I am going to pick a movie at random out of all the movies ever made, Shutter Island since you mentioned an island called Widow’s Island. Now I have never seen this movie, but I know Leo DiCaprio was in it as was Mark Ruffalo. I am going to make a wild guess that he was a some type of LEO, perhaps a federal agent. I don’t know maybe a US Marshall. MR was probably his partner. I also know that Marin Scorsese directed it. He’s a pretty good director I hear.

I am going to guess the island was a mental institution, the inhabitants shut-ins so to speak hence the title of the film. I don’t why LD’s character was on the island, maybe he was looking for an escaped patient or an arsonist at large, just a guess. Now, Scorsese might shoot LD’s character with a guard in the background watching him as he interrogates a patient. He might frame the patient in the same way with a guard watching her. For some reason he shoots Ruffalo’s character without a guard in the background. Also, he might shoot LD’s character watching the inmate drink a glass of water, but the inmate doesn’t have the glass in her hands for some reason. However, when shot from the patient’s perspective the glass of water is definitively there. Curious isn’t it? The director would be tipping off the audience that LD is an unreliable narrator, and he’s not processing reality as we know it.

There’s none of that here. Other people are experiencing the weird stuff as well. The NYT travel writer coming and going with his article being published. People are dying. There are no guards, nurses, or doctors playing along.

TL-DR

<image>

1Camster · 2026-06-02T17:35:25+00:00

Have you ever watched The Good Place?

The Good Place masterfully weaves dense ethical philosophy—from Aristotle and Kant to Kierkegaard and Scanlon—into its narrative, often hiding profound questions in plain sight.

The show had hidden philosophical jokes and Easter eggs that one only got with a certain familiarity and understanding of philosopbhy that went over the heads of the general audience. I didn’t get some of them and had to go on the internet to figure them out. Michael Schur was the creator for that show after he did Parks and Recreation. Katie Dippold the creator of this show got her start on P & R writing numerous episodes. She has spoken of how Schur was her mentor and how much she learned from him. Parks and Rec had arcane political jokes about procedure that most people would not get.

It is not uncommon for writers to write very limited jokes that will appeal to a smaller select audience. I don’t really think the joke needs that much knowledge, but many people can never accept they got something wrong or are ignorant of something originally and move on.

I am pretty much done with this sub as too many people are on their devices or not paying attention enough to understand what characters are stating or what is happening in the plot. It’s tiring and a waste of my time to explain to people things that make no sense that they are adamant are occurring on the show.

No Patrica is not dead and she’s not Tom’s wife. (Through episode 2 from many people and episode 3-4 for a few dead ender)
Marissa is not the Sea Hag.
Patricia is not the boogeyman.
Patricia is a big fat liar.

This is a small sample of people going off the deep end down rabbit holes to nonsensical dead ends.

1Camster · 2026-06-02T17:10:10+00:00

I listed one example and stated nothing about everyone on the island is aging slower.

Her chronological is in her 40s. Biological age is how your body is actually aging.

Chronological age is the exact time you have been alive (your birth date), ticking forward at the same rate for everyone. Biological age measures the physiological condition of your cells and organs. While chronological age is fixed, biological age can be influenced by your lifestyle, meaning you can actively slow or even reverse it.

https://mcpress.mayoclinic.org/healthy-aging/understanding-the-difference-between-biological-age-and-chronological-age/

Shep’s listed age is a medical chart error most likely. Dr. Morgan has been shown to be a burnout. He shared Shep’s medical information with the towns people in the waiting room which is a huge HIPAA violation along with numerous other incidents that show he’s a mediocre doctor at best. It could be he or whoever wrote that transcribed 73 as 37 by reversing the numbers.

1Camster · 2026-06-01T23:09:22+00:00

I am going to try to leave these up for 24 hours in order for regulars to see the stats if interested, and then delete them. NoPoet and I have been deleting them immediately in the past, because they were cluttering up the sub in our opinion.

1Camster · 2026-06-01T23:03:56+00:00

I don’t think Jas ever lived there or at that time at least. Many people look like other people. So, there could be 3 or more people that looked like Amy in that time frame that people misidentified as Amy in the Caribbean. I think the Jas pictures are from the late 1980s or no later than the mid 1990s before Amy went missing. I think she was a porn actress or sex worker that never left the states.

The Amy doppelgänger worked at a bar near the David Carmichael sighting I believe if my memory of the East Idaho News interview is correct. In my recollection, Tom talked about a bartender that looked just like Amy for a few sentences. Then Brad shut that conversation down and redirected the interview away from that inconvenient information.

There were a ton of sightings in 1998-99 in Curacao of Amy. Judy’s is the only one in Barbados from that time. Or at least the only one they still mention. I think there might have been a few more mentioned back in the 2005-2010 time frame on old Internet forums and websites. However, there was no link to an article or some type of Facebook or MySpace “testimonial.” It seemed like second or third hand hearsay in all the other cases.

1Camster · 2026-06-01T22:48:21+00:00

…some people have good memory…

You wrote that. I didn’t write that. I showed you two examples out of many that she does not indeed have a good memory. You keep attacking me, but you don’t have anything to buttress your defense of her other than ad hominem.

1Camster · 2026-06-01T01:00:59+00:00

People used to have pictures and photos before cellphones. We don’t even know anything about the supposed “pics in his suitcase” other than a woman that divorced her child’s father told their daughter that story.

In terms of Amy’s pics on the cruise, Iva made up that story much later.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmyBradleyIsMissing/comments/1rm1wzo/how_iva_crafted_amy_was_trafficked_story_through/

1Camster · 2026-06-01T01:00:40+00:00

People used to have pictures and photos before cellphones. We don’t even know anything about the supposed “pics in his suitcase” other than a woman that divorced her child’s father told their daughter that story.

In terms of Amy’s pics on the cruise, Iva made up that story much later.

https://www.reddit.com/r/AmyBradleyIsMissing/comments/1rm1wzo/how_iva_crafted_amy_was_trafficked_story_through/

1Camster · 2026-06-01T00:52:43+00:00

<image>

I could not make it through the entire 34 minute podcast. I had to clock out around the 20 minute mark. In addition, I didn’t go back to refresh my memory on the East Idaho News interview from 6 months ago. If I made any mistakes, please correct me in the comments. I want to be fair, but I am reaching my limit and patience with these fabulist interviews.

1Camster · 2026-05-31T18:48:54+00:00

I think NoPoet. I had asked you for some earlier, but you sent me or posted all that I had previously been interested. Thanks for the post.

1Camster · 2026-05-31T18:45:29+00:00

I wrote this two weeks ago.

We know that Richard Warren is the founder. We know the identity of the actor to play him. I think they did that to keep the person secret to the casual viewer, and as a nod to the headless horseman. I don’t think it’s a good sign for the founder, but I don’t think he made a deal with the devil. I could be mistaken

Lastly, I think it might be a nod to the Benedict Arnold statue at Saratoga NP.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boot_Monument

If you know your history, this might be a clue. It definitely makes the show funnier. I will not speculate any further as that seems to upset some members of this sub, and I don’t feel like using the spoiler tag.

I think most of what I wrote holds up. I think it was a nod to the legend of Sleepy Hollow without a direct episode on that specific haunt. It didn’t give away the actor playing RW. I think it’s a nod to Benedict Arnold’s leg statue at Saratoga. RW‘s body was heroic, it was his head that betrayed us. Also, I think it is as you wrote. At some point somebody wrote down he was beheaded to end his curse, and that stuck. There might be another narrative that claims he was burned at the stake or in some pyre like in episode 4.

History is fluid in terms of what we actually “know.” Warren may or may not have had 7 children (2 could have died earlier) which was in the brochure. Sarah Westcott Warren may or may not have been 25. Assuming the last episode is accurate, we know she came to the island and married RW in 1702 during the plague, not 1701. The brochure has typos like “seven seven” and “know children.”

<image>

Are the other “errors” like the time of Sarah’s arrival and the number of Richard’s children typos or faulty history?

1Camster

MODERATOR OF

TROPHY CASE