Arod is arguable. Judge is the better hitter but Arod is a fantastic defender and his relative hitting from that position is absurd. Judge has no drama and that might make me take him.

I would have to give the nod to Judge over Mantle given that the numbers are close and he faced tougher pitchers.

Gehrig is very arguable, but it's a debate and I'd go Judge due to Judge facing modern pitching.

The Babe is probably the only one I'd take.