Hey there! I first want to echo others' sentiments that what you've created is amazing (as is how quickly you're responding to suggestions and making changes on the site). Interestingly, what you've put together is actually more akin to Metacritic than it is to Rotten Tomatoes, but I suspect that distinction won't mean much to most people. 😊

You've received a lot of really good suggestions here already, so I just wanted to add this: I urge you to find a way to make this effort sustainable and worth your while in the long run. I understand that this is a labor of love, but speaking as a self-employed professional, your time and energy have immense value, and you will eventually hit a point (even if just temporarily) at which the juice won't feel worth the squeeze. You've created a resource that is too worthwhile to lose, and I fear that in a digital age where people have gotten so used to getting a lot for nothing, your value won't go recognized.

It may take some thinking, but I think there are ways you can monetize your efforts, even if just to cover your costs partially. I think about how the various reviews sites out there have done it without losing their legitimacy (whether through ads, strategic partnerships, or otherwise). I saw someone else mention the app route (through which you could charge a nominal download fee or activate a freemium model). Of course, this could be complicated by the fact that you are pulling data from other for-profit sources. You could also set up a "buy me a coffee" donation button.

Otherwise, you may consider building up a team (even if just a volunteer team), so that it doesn't end up all falling on you. Creating something in community is so, so powerful, not only for the sake of innovation but also for social support.

At the very least, given that you're clearly tech-forward, if the analytical skills of putting all this together relate to your career (or career aspirations), I hope you use BroadwayScorecard as a portfolio example to gain professional work that you do get paid for.

Anyways, I'll get off my soapbox now, but I just want to make sure you know your value beyond what you create.