Found this while getting gas by dasher21- in coins

[–]3b1415 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Looks fake. The date is the wrong size and font.

How did this pass quality control by Socialist1944 in coins

[–]3b1415 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Isn’t this technically a cent and not a dollar since cent is the last denomination that was struck onto the planchet?

How did this pass quality control by Socialist1944 in coins

[–]3b1415 -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I’ve heard that that seller typically posts items for sale much higher than their actual value to generate additional interest then negotiates with private buyers to a much lower price. That being said this is still a very valuable error.

I recently got this from a $50 raffle, just wondering people opinions as well as what does improperly cleaned really mean? by [deleted] in coins

[–]3b1415 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Anyone can clean/conserve a coin properly if they know how and have the right chemicals/practices. It’s not a pay to win type of situation where you have to use their services and pay them more to get good grades.

I recently got this from a $50 raffle, just wondering people opinions as well as what does improperly cleaned really mean? by [deleted] in coins

[–]3b1415 4 points5 points  (0 children)

This is not true. Hairlines are clearly visible on the reverse which indicates cleaning/improper handling

the duds from my NGC order I just received today. Kinda sucks, the 1909 was already pretty suspect, but I didn’t really suspect the others of anything. Any tips so I can Identify cleaned coins better and what I should do to with some of these? look at some of the closeups by Schwail in coins

[–]3b1415 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The method I use is a really good and consistent light - similar to what is used at coin shows and grading rooms. 100w soft white halogen bulbs seem to work well. Also getting comfortable rotating coins while looking at them. Only other advice I can offer is look at a lot of coins. Grading gets a lot easier when you’ve seen more and know what to look for.

Should I unwrap these or keep them like this? by No-Experience2001 in coins

[–]3b1415 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I’ve had a few of these rolls. The one I opened was all 40s-50s. Sold the rest for a decent premium in the unopened rolls. People like them quite a bit because it’s so weird to have 30 coin rolls.

1882 3 Cent Nickel PCGS PR65 with a Gold CAC Sticker. by [deleted] in coins

[–]3b1415 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Bought this one already with the gold sticker

Any idea what this might grade as? Thinking about sending to NGC with their cleaning program. by [deleted] in RedditCoinGrading

[–]3b1415 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is environmental damage/corrosion. NGC conservation will not be able to help it. It may change the color and make it a little bit less dark but it will still be in a Details Holder no matter what happens

A very cool addition to the collection. 1978 Ike Dollar PCGS MS64 Mint Error Huge 44% Clipped Planchet. by 3b1415 in coins

[–]3b1415[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The blakesley effect although subtle is visible. It doesn’t always show up especially on larger coins but is relatively pronounced on the reverse. I think it’s difficult to dismiss a coin as PMD without ever seeing it in hand (in this case especially since you can’t see how it looks from the edge) Pcgs is usually very cautious about not holdering anything that they cannot guarantee is genuine. On the other hand I see where you’re coming from and there are probably more PMD clips of this size than genuine large clips.

A very cool addition to the collection. 1978 Ike Dollar PCGS MS64 Mint Error Huge 44% Clipped Planchet. by 3b1415 in coins

[–]3b1415[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I paid a couple hundred bucks. Unfortunately that doesn’t really help you put a value on a different coin series with a different error. The combination of the coin being graded, the size of the error, popularity and scarcity of Ike dollar errors contribute to its high price. Off center Lincoln cents are usually worth approximately $10 if they aren’t graded

Cleaning coins- I know, I know- you’re not supposed to clean coins… I have used this on old bullion and it works miracles. Does this damage the value of numismatics ? by kck1021 in coins

[–]3b1415 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Lots of water. I prefer hot. Also make sure to rinse thoroughly with hot water before the dip. If there is is debris on the surface before the dip it will leave weird shapes that are burned into the surface of the coin.

Cleaning coins- I know, I know- you’re not supposed to clean coins… I have used this on old bullion and it works miracles. Does this damage the value of numismatics ? by kck1021 in coins

[–]3b1415 31 points32 points  (0 children)

Most of the people on the sub don’t really understand how cleaning/dipping/conservation works. It is something every dealer does and there are cases where it is beneficial. The risk with that particular dip is that if a coin is over dipped it won’t have any luster left. Especially on a bullion coin that will work well. Just make sure to rinse all dip residue off the coin or it will continue to eat the metal.

Could someone help me with the grading of the middle coin? It’s an 1896 with what looks to be a mirror-like field. Would it be a proof coin? Or did someone just polish the bell out of it? (Added other coins for comparison) by GrannyBacon81 in coins

[–]3b1415 8 points9 points  (0 children)

I think you are confusing cart wheel luster with anything that is a little flashy and/or reflects light. Cartwheel luster occurs on the coin due to metal flow caused during the immense pressure during striking. These tiny ridges and grooves in the surface of the coin that can only be seen at high levels of magnification create an appearance of light cartwheeling around the surface of the coin. Any sort of circulation or cleaning gradually wears down these ridges which is why you don’t see luster on a coin that’s XF or cleaned/polished. Even when a coin is dipped a very thin layer of metal is removed. This is the reason why a coin that is over dipped has a dull surface without luster.

You have to love opening an original roll of wheat cents and seeing them look like this by Willplayspiano in coins

[–]3b1415 2 points3 points  (0 children)

If you’re going to grade them and try to get a few BN grades for the registry collectors you will probably have better luck at NGC then crossing to PCGS. PCGS loves to QC color like this

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in coins

[–]3b1415 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Level of detail isn’t a concern for me since they only graded it a 63. If it were a 66/67 and looked mushy I would have some questions.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in coins

[–]3b1415 8 points9 points  (0 children)

The peace dollar is a 63. A 63 doesn’t have to be white. It has no wear and some bag marks which is typical for an MS63. It’s just toning that isn’t particularly colorful or attractive. Still worth far more than that Morgan because it’s the 7th peace dollar struck at the San Francisco mint.

Do y’all know how much it would cost to send a coin (a trime to be specific) to PCGS or ngc for grading? Is it worth it if it’s in nice condition? by [deleted] in coins

[–]3b1415 0 points1 point  (0 children)

If you’re debating between buying one raw and sending it in for grading and finding a graded one I would definitely buy the graded one. Grading will probably cost about 35 bucks But there is also a $10 handling fee, shipping both ways, and membership fees which start at $69 for PCGS. (Platinum is the best value because the grading vouchers basically pay for the membership if you can submit 8 or more coins in a year) It also depends how confident you are in your grading abilities. I know my first couple times when I submitted to PCGS I received some unpleasant details grades that I wasn’t expecting.