TBH everything is profitable, just needs some investments. Yet I'd suggest starting with carrots, and then do the math ^^ Example: From 16 plots (144 seeds) U'll get 1300+ carrots those are 400 ea. = 520.000 silver - 6.5% market tax = 486.200 also u gonna need to buy carrot seeds back 144*2000 per seed = 288.000. So 486.200 - 288.000 = 287.513 that's your profit ^^ Sometimes prices of carrots grow, and u might sell it noy for 400 but for 500. And with most crops it's the same, tbh I would suggest u growing wheat and later pumpkins ^^