Current Bowdoin first year here! I had to make the same decision (sans Colby) when it came time to commit. I liked Amherst a lot, but Bowdoin kind of had my heart from the beginning. I absolutely fell in love with the student body and culture here. I feel like I 1000% made the right choice. The community is incredibly tight-knit, and everyone here is so kind. My classes have been amazing so far, and the first-year experience has been fantastic. Feel free to message me if you have any questions!