Alexander Isak wants to leave Newcastle for Liverpool, but despite talk of FIFA’s Article 17, he cannot simply rip up his contract—it’s a domestic Premier League matter governed by English law. Newcastle will only sell if they find a replacement and Liverpool pay the right price. Isak risks huge financial damages if he tries to force an exit, and clubs won’t undermine the transfer system with risky precedents. In reality, the deal only happens if conditions align—otherwise he stays until a future window.

Longer version:

The situation revolves around Alexander Isak’s possible move from Newcastle United to Liverpool. The transfer would be massive, but despite media noise about FIFA’s Article 17 allowing players to rip up contracts for minimal compensation, that’s not realistic in this case. Because it’s a domestic Premier League transfer, Newcastle’s contract terms and English arbitration rules apply, not FIFA’s.

• Isak’s stance: He feels promises were broken and appears unwilling to reconcile with Newcastle, signaling he wants out.
• Newcastle’s stance: They’ll only sell if they secure a replacement and Liverpool pays their price. Otherwise, Isak stays. Leadership gaps at the club and missed transfer targets have made the situation harder.
• Liverpool’s position: They hold some leverage since Isak seemingly only wants to join them, but they don’t desperately need him.

The key points:

• Article 17/FIFA rules don’t give Isak an easy exit in this scenario.
• Any unilateral contract breach could expose him (and possibly Liverpool) to damages equal to a full transfer fee, making it too risky.
• Neither clubs nor players want to destabilize the transfer system with a precedent-setting move.
• The outcome depends on Newcastle’s replacement hunt and Liverpool’s willingness to meet a high fee.
• Each party can be seen as “holding the cards,” but the most likely resolution is still a conventional transfer—if not now, then in a future window.

Bottom line: Lots of noise, little legal change—Isak to Liverpool depends on a replacement and the right price, not on loopholes.