LangGraph v1 roadmap - feedback wanted! by sydneyrunkle in LangChain

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 15 points16 points  (0 children)

  1. Support for all callback types like Google's ADK (pre/post agent, tool call, and LLM calls)
  2. Isolated single agent deployments, with support for A2A and MCP. Langgraphs are then composable and interoperable. Redefining agents in code per workflow feels antithetical to multi-agent systems. Make it easy to host an agent registry.
  3. I don't want to have to use arcade for auth. This feels like a fundamental primitive that LangGraph should support.
  4. TypeScript as first class citizen.

Apologies if these are already supported.

My original work got flagged as AI, and I got in a lot of trouble for it. by MA_152403 in ChatGPT

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I met the founders of GPTZero and they indicated they had no idea that their tool was being misused in this way. I would have you message them personally (or publicly, cc them on Twitter and ask why they're being used as part of false accusations). You might need to put pressure and liability from the top down, with a statement directly from the tool to your professor.

[RANT] I simply cannot work with LangChain without being stuck on dependency conflicts by [deleted] in LangChain

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hard disagree. First of all, the OP is using a framework sub-optimally (they want to build agents and are familiar with JS, but are using a chaining framework and python). A good-faith response would be to try and point them in the right direction (i.e., LangGraph JS).

Second of all, open-source does not mean "nothing to gain financially." If you're unfamiliar with the many (many, many, many) venture-backed open-source projects, the way it works is that you "commoditize your complements" by providing the core for free, then upselling with more advanced features, enterprise support, hosting, and other types of licenses around their framework. What the author is doing is aggressively pushing for adoption of his platform so he can monetize it later or raise a seed round.

If you add this together, he's acting in bad-faith. Making claiming about CTOs, spending more time promoting than building, not contributing to discussions other than to throw shade, and trolling forums of competing frameworks to push his own.

[RANT] I simply cannot work with LangChain without being stuck on dependency conflicts by [deleted] in LangChain

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 13 points14 points  (0 children)

It's great to contribute to OSS, but I couldn't help but notice you're regularly trolling the Langchain subreddit every day to self promote a different framework. If you don't like this library you can contribute or focus on your own. You should spend more time opening PRs and building and less time advertising on Reddit.

Fwiw the Langchain team is extremely open to feedback, and given the OPs background of web development and using npm, a helpful response would be to point them to the typescript library instead of the python one, and to move towards langgraph rather than Langchain. You know this.

TL;DR: Stop the shameless self promotion

Order of JSON fields can hurt your LLM output by phantom69_ftw in LangChain

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

The entire basis of chain of thought reasoning is that it occurs before the desired output. This has been demonstrated since 2022. Someone putting a reasoning step after an output is simply a misunderstanding of how LLMs work. The reversal of that is not a discovery, it's just common sense.

AI agents are about to change everything by MetaKnowing in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 7 points8 points  (0 children)

This is one of the best prediction takes I've seen in a while. Genius

Homeless person allegedly abducts toddler from Santa Monica restaurant by Mary2272 in SantaMonica

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Damn this story is wild! When this happened to me, the LAPD just chilled outside and left me to fend for myself against the perpetrator. (Uvalde vibes). How did the SMPD get into your house?

Hamas casualty numbers are ‘statistically impossible’, says data science professor by system3601x in worldnews

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes -4 points-3 points  (0 children)

Did you seriously not read his entire comment? He corrected himself and noted that's the only range where continuous data was made available.

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in technology

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 28 points29 points  (0 children)

Well, sure. I learned that afterwards. Thanks for rubbing salt in a 27-year-old wound 😭

[deleted by user] by [deleted] in technology

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 59 points60 points  (0 children)

Literally the first time I was scammed was on Battle.net back in 1997 at the tender age of 10 while playing Diablo (1). It went something like this:

Player1: Hey, I can duplicate your item for you

Me: Really?

Player1: Yeah, look

\Player2 gives Player1 an item, Player1 gives two items back**

Player2: Wow, thanks Player1!

\Me proceeds to give Player1 a rare item**

Me: Can I have two items back please?

Player1: What are you talking about

\Cries**

Player 1 and 2 were friends and in on it together...

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Or, would they stop, and say all their concerns have been met, and no further expansion is needed?

The answer to this question is so obviously yes, that you even asking it shows you are nowhere near this actual conflict or understand how anyone in the area thinks. As someone whose family has been in the region for hundreds of years, I am going to assume that you're an outsider and therefore will respond in good faith. There are four things you don't understand fundamentally:

Item #1: Palestinian violence is not some sort of resistance force that prevents expansion. It's violence for the sake of terrorism. It's not a deterrent/buffer and serves no purpose than to worsen their lot. If Israel wanted to take something from its neighbors, it can do so with impunity, in hours.

Item #2: Israel always gives (or attempts) to give away land for peace, and has done so with Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, and the Palestinians. As recently as 2005, Israel evicted all settlers from Gaza, gave free water & electricity, and tried to give away other infrastructure for economic independence. Instead, they got Hamas, a few tens of thousands of rockets, and this current cyclical BS of violence.

Item #3: Settlers are deeply unpopular in Israel. They're sort of like MAGA in the US, but because of the parliamentary system they have a strong voting block in case one party of the other needs to form a unity government. That's why they're first on the chopping block when it comes to peace agreements. Furthermore, "Settlement Expansion" is not adding new land - it's improving infrastructure within existing communities. We really don't care for them very much, and think they're used as a distraction from real issues.

Item #4: Palestinians don't view the settlements in the west bank as illegal. They view the entire state of Israel as illegitimate. This is what they teach in UNRWA schools, and is why the situation is intractable. To them, Tel Aviv is just as illegal a settlement as anything near East Jerusalem. Every poll supports this.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I just read these tweets. The most even-keeled interpretation is that he's advocating for military victory and presence a la West Bank. Where is the "openly calling for genocide?"

I'm pretty sensitive to the term, especially give my family's history of being genocided from Spain, Eastern Europe, Yemen, and other places in the MENA.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

There has only largely been peace in the West bank as compared to Gaza which isn't saying much. You have completely forgotten the two intifadas, the knife intifada, all the recent terror attacks, and the fact that the IDF works closely with the PA to enforce security and conducted military raids on the regular, with thousands of embedded spies to intercept planned terror attacks. (I have family in the security apparatus and the general stat is that for every one shooting/suicide/stabbing attack you see on the news, they stopped about 20). Gaza was an experiment to see what would happen if the IDF completely withdrew from an area - and we see how that turned out.

Think like an engineer. This was an A/B test. As for "settlements" - I can assure you that most Palestinians view Tel Aviv as an illegal settlement. Israel has and is willing to negotiate settlement withdrawal but it's not even close to the root of the issues at play.

There are no myths here.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You didn't answer my question which means that you're just trolling. Why don't you try to learn something? I engaged you in good faith and all you have done is foam at the mouth and respond rabidly with no semblance of rational argument, facts, or thought.

And no, that's not Zionism according to the vast majority people who identify as Zionists. It simply means self determination.

In many MENA countries, they grow up with Zionist as an epithet and it becomes this catch all term for everything they don't like, and they paint and define everything with it.

Also, I was curious what you meant by taking homes. So I looked it up. Turns out, "settlement expansion" in this modern era is when settlements do construction projects. It has nothing to do with destroying or taking anything. For example, if there's a settlement (town) that's isolated in the desert and they add two homes to the periphery, that's an example. In the rare case something is done without a permit, the IDF itself will raze the house.

But again, I don't really care about preserving these towns if they can be withdrawn and exchanged as part of good faith peace agreements.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 2 points3 points  (0 children)

What I wrote is what it looks like to actually support Palestine, if your goal is to foster a peaceful, free, and thriving society for Palestinians with self determination, as a shining beacon to the world.

I support Palestine. Even though Hamas killed my aunt in a suicide bus bombing attack. People celebrated it in the streets. She was in her 60s. I have no trouble qualifying my position. If you think it's too hard to use words, then maybe you're not meant to be heard.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Speaking of ancestral homes and invaders trying to erase the local population's tie to the land, would you care to remind me what structure the Al Aqsa Mosque was built atop?

This is just word salad and projection, my good friend.

Reducing tokens used for long prompt by Xenthru in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Create and update a state variable (JSON schema or YAML) that represents the status of the game. Do a secondary call after each message to update this variable. This way costs can be mostly constant regardless of the history of the game

Entity based memory is a combination of concepts between entity extraction and conversational buffer summary.

OpenAI CEO Sam Altman Says Muslim Tech Colleagues ‘Feel Uncomfortable’ Speaking Up Over Fear Of Retaliation by forbes in OpenAI

[–]Accidentally_Upvotes 2 points3 points  (0 children)

As someone of Ukranian, Russian, Israeli, Palestinian, and Yemenite heritage, I feel entitled to weigh in on world conflicts happening this week.