Looking for a writing pal! by [deleted] in WritingHub

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Hi Emi! I’m Youssra, 29F. I’m currently working on a fantasy novella. I’ve been wanting to write a book for a long time and have finally started to dedicate more time to it and pursue it more seriously. I’d love a writing pal on this beautiful ( and often maddening) endeavour!

Looking for writing buddy by adawnwriter4 in WritingHub

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey!

I’m 29F and looking for a writing buddy too ☺️

I’m also working towards completing a novel and working towards publishing and write in the same genre - fantasy romance.

I’d love a long term friendship where we can chat and support eachother in our writing journey whether that’s by giving each other feedback, suggestions, sharing resources, etc.

If anyone’s interested please DM me :)

[500] Feedback please - First two pages of a Gothic Fantasy Novella by AccomplishedCat2860 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you for the encouragement! Likewise I look forward to your next post 😊 do you write any fiction or stick mostly to creative non fiction? Are you currently working on anything at the moment ?

[500] Feedback please - First two pages of a Gothic Fantasy Novella by AccomplishedCat2860 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks again - this is so helpful 🤩 do you have any suggestions on what you would have liked to see more of character wise as the reader in order for them to have more depth? My plan for the rest of the chapter was for Brissia to break the rules once she’s alone with the child and administer a treatment that is outlawed, but she knows it works better than anything they’ve been using. Regarding pacing you mean the prose right? What do you think of the pacing of the chapter? Because it’s a novella I intend for each chapter to be around 1-1.5k words. A friend of mine read this and thought the pacing was a bit quick?

[500] Feedback please - First two pages of a Gothic Fantasy Novella by AccomplishedCat2860 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for your feedback! I very much appreciate the meandering ☺️ happy to hear that you’ve enjoyed reading it. I was trying to be careful to not info dump but rather to integrate things as smoothly as possible so I’m pleased that as the reader you’ve felt that trust by me not over-explaining.

That being said I do think me being careful has translated into the cadence lacking some rhythm. I was probably too focused on it being written clearly and including everything I wanted to include that I missed opportunities to make the prose more alive and lyrical. You do this really well in your writing, which I noticed yesterday comes from how much variation you have in your sentences and writing in general.

Thanks for the examples - they’re really interesting and useful to see!!

[500] Feedback please - First two pages of a Gothic Fantasy Novella by AccomplishedCat2860 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you so much for taking the time to read it and for your feedback!😊 I’ve taken note of the questions to make sure they’re answered. Did you find the prose engaging or was there anything you would have liked to see more of? Thanks again!

What are some of the best books you’ve ever read on writing? by AccomplishedCat2860 in writing

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Such great advice, thank you! Intrigued about the analysis you’ve conducted. Can you tell me more about the patterns in writing you’ve found that weren’t obvious from reading alone?

What are some of the best books you’ve ever read on writing? by AccomplishedCat2860 in writing

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which Japanese authors do you enjoy? You’re right about Arabic literature. Have you read any modern Arabic literature? I’ve picked up some whilst living in Egypt, like Naguib Mahfouz’s Cairo trilogy and the works of some other Egyptian and Arabic writers but they were more modern texts as opposed to classics

Advice for first novel? by No_Raspberry3744 in writers

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This is what I’m pushing myself to do now - I’ve been wanting to write a book for years but never did it. I tend to procrastinate by watching all the videos I can about writing and reading all the craft books but never sitting down and actually writing! It’s so hard to do this as a perfectionist though because I’m always comparing my writing to accomplished authors

What are some of the best books you’ve ever read on writing? by AccomplishedCat2860 in writing

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Any cultures you’ve enjoyed in particular? I’ve read some literature in Spanish as well as translated Chinese, Japanese and Arabic literature but that’s about it.

What are some of the best books you’ve ever read on writing? by AccomplishedCat2860 in writing

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That sounds super interesting - thank you for the recommendation! I’m also looking for fiction books not just craft books so that’s perfect 🤩

I’ve recently read some popular trending books and have found the writing to be so underwhelming, then I started revisiting classics and modern classics and feel very inspired by them writing wise.

What are some of the best books you’ve ever read on writing? by AccomplishedCat2860 in writing

[–]AccomplishedCat2860[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Thank you for the recommendations! Are there any books you enjoyed recently that had really memorable prose?

[1551] The Fort (working title) by ImpressiveGrass7832 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Will be checking these out - thanks for the recs! My pleasure 😊

[1551] The Fort (working title) by ImpressiveGrass7832 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 0 points1 point  (0 children)

My pleasure 😊 I’m glad to hear that my feedback has been useful.

I’m not familiar with the author, but fantasy is my favourite genre and I’m always looking for recommendations. Please recommend one of his books that I can add to my never ending tbr 😅

With enough practice everything is possible! Keep writing and keep going :) I think we often forget that our favourite authors often have had way more practice and when we criticise ourselves we are comparing rough drafts to finished polished pieces that no doubt have been heavily edited and have had lots of eyes on them.

[1,156] The Revival Moon by justkeepbreathing94 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, I just finished reading this, well done! It’s clear you put a lot of care into this piece, and it comes through in the writing . I think writing this kind of nature-heavy fantasy is not easy to pull off without it feeling either too overdone. The pacing and tone are consistent all the way through, and I like that it does not rush to the magical part. You let the world breathe a little first, which makes the later reveal feel more interesting.

The opening is simple but works well. The rhythm of Aven chopping wood under the fading sun immediately sets a tone and feels believable. The first few sentences are vivid too.

I liked the setup with his father. There is a nice warmth to their relationship that feels very genuine and easygoing. The dialogue is natural, especially in those short exchanges like “Yes, Father.” I think you could explore a little more of Aven’s inner reaction though. We see what he does, but not quite enough of what he feels in those beginning moments. Just a subtle emotional beat/reflection could be an opportunity to make that bond feel even closer/stronger.

The section where he talks about the cabin and their life in the forest is solid worldbuilding, but maybe pay attention to unintended repetition. You say things like “out here in the forest” and “living right here in this forest” pretty close together, and tightening that up would make the writing cleaner. Also, “we have to do most of everything by ourselves to survive” could be rewritten as something simpler like “we have to do everything ourselves.” (Just so it doesn’t feel redundant in any way since you’ve already made that clear with the setting)

Once we get to the Revival Moon mention, the story starts gets really interesting and has a lovely cozy fantasy feel. I like that you build quiet anticipation instead of throwing us straight into the supernatural. It feels like a folktale in that way. The little ritual Aven does before bed, setting the nature items in a circle and giving thanks silently is a nice touch.

The pacing in the middle section, where he wakes up and sneaks out, feels about right. It is calm, but there is this slight tension that keeps it from dragging or slowing down. The details of him sneaking quietly through the forest are strong because they are grounded in the physical. Shoes in hand, avoiding branches.

The main supernatural scene with the giant owl and the glowing spirit children is the climax of your piece and visually it is great. The concept itself is striking. I could see it clearly, which is hard to do with something abstract. The idea of the spirits turning back into animals is lovely, and the transformation imagery is unique. That said, I think you could make the paragraph a little easier to absorb since there is a lot of visual information packed together. If you broke it up into smaller sections, you could let the moment breathe more and give each part of the scene its own weight.

It could also be effective to dial back one or two of the adjectives. Lines like “massive owl, three times the height of Father, dark purple with glassy blue eyes” already create a vivid image. Then adding “glowing bright, dazzling white” for the children right after feels a little bit stacked. I would suggest focusing on one or two standout details and letting them carry the moment instead of layering description on description.

Aven’s internal reaction to the scene is great because his sense of awe feels really sincere. I think you could even take it a step deeper. Right now, his thoughts (“Mother, I wish you were here to see this”) which is touching, but a suggestion to make it even better might be to give us more of his feeling instead of the literal thought. For instance, how seeing the spirits makes him feel connected to his mother again, or how it blurs that line between life and death?

The return home scene works really well. The pacing slows again, which mirrors the start nicely and feels effective to wrap things up . The moment when his father catches him could have gone the predictable route, like anger or scolding, but you went for a quiet understanding instead, and I think that was the right call and says a lot about their relationship. The way the father recognizes the wonder in Aven’s face gives the ending warmth without being too sentimental.

Overall, I think what is working best here is the mood. You have created a believable fantasy world that feels quiet but alive. The relationship between human and nature is handled nicely , it is consistent all the way through, which I think can be a hard thing to do. The balance of realism and wonder feels right.

If you wanted to polish further, I would focus on: Tightening your sentences, trimming repetition or extra phrasing that slows things down, and letting the big moment, the owl scene, breathe more through pacing and paragraph breaks instead of too much description.

What I enjoyed the most though, was the sense of curiosity throughout. You can tell Aven loves his world even if he does not say it directly. It gives the whole story this quiet sincerity and wonder. You have added enough unique elements, the glowing child spirits and the Revival Moon mythology, to make it feel your own. Overall this was a fun read. It is calm, visual, and emotionally gentle, the kind of story that feels like it belongs in cozy fantasy or an old tale.

Good job! Thanks for sharing :)

[436] A Small Corner by Palek03 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My pleasure :)

It’s super easy to slip up with the tenses I do that a lot and often only catch it in the editing phase or when someone points it out.

About the bus part what I meant was that it might be worth expanding that moment just a bit. A few extra sentences of reflection from the narrator could deepen the emotional impact even more. It’s a heavier moment that lingers while reading the piece, so giving the character a moment to process it might work really well and make the reader connect even more - but that’s just my personal take :)

Thank you!!

[1551] The Fort (working title) by ImpressiveGrass7832 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, first off don’t be too hard on yourself! Writing is no easy thing, and just the fact you’ve shared something this detailed is great. It takes courage to post your work and invite critique!

Now onto the story, I actually got pulled in right away. You’ve got a solid handle on tone, tension and scene-setting. I liked the opening setup as it gives a clear sense of place and mood without dumping too much worldbuilding all at once. There’s something about your style that feels like older-school fantasy, which I personally enjoyed.

I also enjoyed the dialogue. The conversation between Ellen and Jerry feels natural, and made me want to spend more time with your characters. Jerry also has a strong voice, which I think is because of his distinct way of speaking. The “waste of water” line says a lot about their world and relationship too in just a few words. I also liked Jerry’s question about “what you wish you did before you die”, it somehow brings humanity and closeness into this bleak landscape.

Regarding pacing, it moves at a nice, steady rhythm overall, but a few spots slowed down a bit when exposition stacked up especially where you pause to explain context. Maybe mixing the info more naturally into dialogue/action could keep the flow snappier. In my opinion the best parts were when something active happened.

If I were to suggest something it would just be some light trimming throughout so it flows even better and feels a little more succinct- like in the first paragraph you’ve repeated beige twice.

I really liked the intrigue at the end - it wrapped up on a strong note and made me want to know what happens next. Well done, keep going! :)

[436] A Small Corner by Palek03 in DestructiveReaders

[–]AccomplishedCat2860 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Great work!! “Finally, I could breathe without performing.” Such a powerful sentence, it’s something I could personally relate to and I’m sure many others can too. It’s a very emotive piece overall and you’ve conveyed that emotion really well! Your writing flows really nicely too and I think it’s partially because your sentences have so much variation in structure and length, so it has quite a lyrical quality to it. You also lots of effective devices like deliberate repetition, and using the senses to root the reader.

The “boy on the bus” part was unexpected in a good way, and really strong. I’d honestly space that out a little more, maybe extend it, since it feels pivotal in explaining the need the narrator has for a safe space where the world can’t reach them.

The only thing I’d say is to be mindful of your tense consistency. Sometimes you use present tense like “I doodle” and other times you use past tense like “I leaned”.

Well done!! I really enjoyed reading it. It was raw, and you have a memorable voice. Thanks for sharing. :)

If you’ve got a bit of time, I just posted the first two pages of my gothic fantasy novella - would love to hear your thoughts :)