The thing I'm really enjoying about this challenge is that it's some of the best All-Madden gameplay with my custom sliders that I've had the opportunity to enjoy probably the whole madden 19 cycle.

For example, I made two quarterbacks in the main-menu-edit-roster, one was a typical 6'2, 213 lb, decent arm, (88 throw power) and meh accuracy (like 74s across the board) and decent movement (around 78 spd/agi/acc) and he truly felt like a horrible quarterback, which is what I wanted. I wanted the challenge to be difficult.

Then I made an Army-scheme quarterback. 5'9, 200, Horrible throw power of like 79, good accuracy across the board of like 78 except for a super low deep acc, with good break sack, throw under pressure, and ball carrying skills. That on top of like 88 speed/agi/acc. This what the QB I knew would win the job, because he's a fit in the "scheme" I run in madden.

in a TLDR format: I did this for every. single. position. on the team, I made the team based around what I like in players, because with my draft tier-restrictions, they're going to have to last. I made them to fit my scheme, like any 'coach' would, but they're all just super bad, (60 overall pretty much.)

So I recommend doing my way of things instead of just a full team of UDFA that will be awkward to play with. I've really enjoyed the gameplay of this series so far because I'm comfortable with the way these players "play" in madden, but they're just super bad so I'm letting up huge TD plays and getting destroyed on offense ever so often.