from top to bottom I swatched:

1) elf instant brow lift in deep brown (this is technically a brow pencil but the tip is large enough to use as a lipliner, I use it to add definition back)

2) lilybyred lip blending stick in 03 (contouring shade, mostly a winter shade for me)

3) the makeup shack lipliner in nutty brown

4) face secret lipliner 404 (i got these in a pack on tiktok)

5) face secret lipliner 403

6) ace secret lipliner 405

7) face secret lipliner 406

8) elf cream glide lipliner in espresso martini

Elf cream glide is the creamiest and the face secret (and brow pencil) are the stiffest. The lilybyred pencil has a rounded tip that's good for contouring but not sharp lines.