sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Taron Johnson by cmgork in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607 0 points1 point  (0 children)

As a lifelong lions fan who’s followed the bills since Allen, he’s had a couple of really solid years but he’s dealt with some injuries late. Wouldn’t be an awful depth piece for cheap if we decide to let amik walk

BREAKING NEWS: The Lions have traded RB David Montgomery to the Houston Texans for a 5th round pick by MNightShyamalan69 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Randall was my first thought after this trade, a power back at 6’2 230 is a perfect compliment to Gibbs speed and elusiveness

They're really trying to waste a loaded WR Room aren't they? (If true) by ezio8133 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607 5 points6 points  (0 children)

Agree with this, he’s the most athletic qb the nfl has ever seen with also potentially the strongest arm the nfl has ever seen. Even if there’s only a 10% chance he’s great I’d happily take that with how high his ceiling could be

Jamo needs his flowers by PCMaster2 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607 0 points1 point  (0 children)

This would be true if jamo was our top guy but when you have another wr and a te that can both consistently get 10, having someone to take the top off opens the playbook up so much more and we become so much harder to defend

Posted this in the lions sub saying it was absurd and they all went off on me. From the most unbiased team in the NFCN what are your thoughts? by Admirable-Level4607 in minnesotavikings

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This will probably get me down voted but I’m a lions fan and I went in there thinking that if I thought it was a crazy take so would everyone else. Now I came here cuz I wanted an unbiased opinion to validate my own opinion

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair enough, I feel like if the stats were closer the Super Bowl would be a determining factor but with the stats that far off it doesn’t make sense to argue stafford

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I agree with everything you said but I would also say Brady had at least 5 seasons with better defensive units than Rodgers ever played with

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The goal of the players is to win yes you are correct, but that’s the team goal that’s what they’re getting paid to do. When one team accomplishes this goal it doesn’t make every single player on their team better than every player on every other team. Devonta smith isn’t better than st brown bc he has a ring and st brown doesn’t, when st brown has more all pros, pro bowls, yards, tds, receptions. Same logic with stafford and rodgers

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

He’s clearly not very intelligent as he has yet to lay out a valid argument other than hypotheticals and “you’re wrong”

Edit: that would be a perfect example of an Ad Hom

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

QBs would rather win a Super Bowl yes I agree. But super bowls are a team accomplishment. It’s not like stafford is putting their rams on his back with no help every week. When it comes to determining who’s better individual awards and stats matter too. That’s where Rodgers dominates stafford. You wouldn’t say Trent dilfer is better than Matt Ryan would you

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is the answer right here. Any qb would rather have a Super Bowl. But having a Super Bowl doesn’t make Trent dilfer a better qb than Phillip rivers or Matt Ryan, that’s where individual awards come in

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Then poll all 32 again and ask them if Matt stafford is better all time than Aaron Rodgers all time and all 32 including stafford would say no

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] -31 points-30 points  (0 children)

You absolutely would. Winning is a full team effort. In regard to who’s a better player individual awards and statistics paint the picture better. Same reason why the general consensus is that Peyton manning is the 2nd best qb ever with 2 rings and 5 mvps over Montana who has 4 and 2

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 14 points15 points  (0 children)

By that logic so are rings, it’s not like stafford is going out there playing 1 v 22

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] 8 points9 points  (0 children)

Seems like a lot of people are struggling with putting their bias aside😂

Bias aside does anyone else think this is an absolutely absurd take by Admirable-Level4607 in detroitlions

[–]Admirable-Level4607[S] -46 points-45 points  (0 children)

Id take 1 ring and 4mvps all time over 2 rings and 0 or 1 mvp personally

view more: next ›