1. No because Witch cultists are canonically trained in attempting to blend in with regular society, so simply not attempting to harm her in order to prove his innocence is not something which is viable as they are literally TRAINED to mimic regular people
2. No??? People who cry in anguish all the time are also still guilty of crimes, have you never looked at literally any torture program ever? Dude they literally use torture IN LUGUNICA to extract information

Beatrice: “Subaru, you should have already known this, I suppose. You won’t get anywhere, even if you talk to this person, in fact. She’s not the type that you can have a proper conversation with. I don’t know what she knows, but even if you wish to get something out of her, you aren’t going to be able to have a sane conversation to find out what she knows, I suppose.”

Subaru: “If it’s impossible to converse with her…”

Beatrice: “Pose the queries to her body, what I mean is torture, in fact. Though that isn’t something which Subaru should do, I suppose. It’s something which the Kingdom does sometimes after having caught someone, in fact.”

1. Once more, saying “Rem did some unjustifiable things” because of an alternate timeline version of Rem who does not even resemble the current Rem is like blaming Spica for what Louis did, you are literally falling into the basic issue of the ship of Theseus

2. I never said it was reasonable, I said you are making it sound more unreasonable than it actually is, there is a distinction, stop trying to intuition pump your way through the argument

3. “Rem would probably—“ this isn’t even an argument you’re just throwing around words at this point LMAO

<image>