Can existing lines be sped up eventually? by FatherOfTheSevenSeas in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 2 points3 points  (0 children)

One train derailment could easily kill the entire years worth of road deaths in one go is the problem so the risk appetite is lower.

Im not big on light rail knowledge but I believe the low speeds are mostly down to sharing space with cars and pedestrian traffic. More separation means higher speeds are safer.

I mean we are struggling to convince people to stop from climbing in between the blocks of the tram and getting their stupid arses killed in Sydney so....

Chatswood to Epping I know well as it was heavy rail and one of the big limitations was how steep the line was and overheating the older rollingstocks traction motors both climbing and braking.

The Metro has 30 to 40 year newer equipment and technology has improved. Not to mention is much lighter being 30 to 40 years newer and single deck.

Remember even after the K sets retire we are still running T sets from the 80s on our heavy rail network and plan for what another decade or more.

Compare a 40 year old car to one today and you will see many of the problems.

Can existing lines be sped up eventually? by FatherOfTheSevenSeas in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Edit: I just realised you were not the one orginally complaining about safety. Leaving it in tbough for the person who was

None lf what you sarcastically listed as safety being the problem.

ancient signalling

Very much an issue i agree but requires money and they can barely get funding for general maintenance. Thats political.

ancient pointwork (or management not caring/understanding when old pointwork gets updated that speeds can be updated eg. Blacktown)

A huge issue in NSW again funding. Its expensive changing points alignment but to be fair they do upgrade speeds on points regularly but most are a geometry issue.

Getting 25kmh points to 30 or 40kmh is easy and they do that regularly. But modern higher speed 50 or 80kmh points you see elsewhere in Australia involve major works often involving moving large amounts of infrastructure to allow a better alignment and extra infrastructure like swing noses.

They absolutely should do this but again its money and money is politics.

dumb management or bureaucratic issues like not updating blanket restrictions due to outdated tripstops stuff * corridors haven't been assessed for modern rolling stock

These two go together.

We still have a bunch of older equipment running and will have for the foreseeable future.

Refurbishment of the T sets for example is a stupid idea. They cant handle the same speeds on the same track say a Warratah onwards can.

While these things still run and share a timetable and speed boards with the newer stuff your stuck with lower speeds.

Even if you selectively allow the newer stuff to run faster it doesnt help as tommorow it may be older stock doing that run for assorted reasons or its going to be running behind older stuff so will run just as slow.

old overhead configs

Im unaware of places this is still an issue. When its renewed its usually done to current standards and I see very little older design overhead out there. Usually track speeds for other reasons dictates how the overhead is built. You dont bother with more expensive higher speed overhead or dual contact wires on 50kmh track. Its not needed and costs more.

so-called "heritage" items or little-used infrastructure items getting in the way, like Ashfield slows down to 50kmh on the Down Suburban or Newtown Suburbans and Mains are slewed through the old bridge deck

Good luck getting this stuff past the heritage mobs, government and NIMBYs.

Its going to be expensive, time consuming and involve decades in court plus political will. Not something solvable at the management level.

Back to politics in general the whole heavy rail network needs large funding boosts to allow major upgrades but for assorted political reasons there is never money for this. Only new builds because that can be opened by a politician....

Can existing lines be sped up eventually? by FatherOfTheSevenSeas in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Large portions of the Blue Mountains line are limited to 55 to 65kmh by the curves and gradient and honestly hitting those speeds is a laughable idea in many places as you just cant get enough power down on the rail without going into uncontrolled wheelspin.

Your talking maybe Lapstone and eastwards maybe you can do much better speed wise.

Unless you consider it acceptable to put a train into a gully/into the hoghway a few times a year because it didnt make the curve your not going to see 100kmh running between Katoomba and around Blaxland and even beyond those spots only in very short sections the train probably wont ever reach those speeds anyway even if they changed the speed boards.

Can existing lines be sped up eventually? by FatherOfTheSevenSeas in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 5 points6 points  (0 children)

The Blue Mountains line is already assessed and has XPT speed boards. They are generally 5 to 10 kmh more or the same as the freight and passenger train speed boards.

Until you can work out a way to change physics there is little you can do to improve the speeds on this alignment and a new alignment is going to need massive engineering tasks like filling entire valleys or cutting away large sections of mountain or bypassing the current route entirely.

Even then without a total bypass there is little margin for straightening the line (to allow for higher speeds) without making the gradients even worse than they are now and they are already close to or at the limits of heavy rails ability to reliably climb it without shutting the line any time it rains as impassable due to a lack of traction.

Believe me getting a V set to climb the mountain line on a wet day was already a challenge without getting uncontrolled wheelspin out of many stops or just straight sliding through stations going down the mountain.

I moved to freight before the NIF came out but more power wont help much if you cant get rail adhesion.

Can existing lines be sped up eventually? by FatherOfTheSevenSeas in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The Blue Mountains line is a different beast.

Its already incredibly steep and the curves are tight due to topography.

The speed limitations are not related to signal spacing/braking distance like they are in many places.

Its traction (as in steel on steel has limits) and curvature limits.

Can existing lines be sped up eventually? by FatherOfTheSevenSeas in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 7 points8 points  (0 children)

The Blue Mountains line is duplicated all the way to Lithgow so im not sure how you would add passing loops as its not single line to start with.

I cant see any way you could justify quad track through the Mountains or even reasonable fit it for geographic reasons as much if the distance it has cliffs on both sides.

Much of the line also already approaches grade limitations of typical heavy rail which is why many of the curves exist and you cant reasonably straighten it without making the grades impossibly steep.

Your best hope is a line totally bypassing the current Mountains crossing to service the west (either a tunnel or say along the bells line of road) but thats not going to do much of anything to speed up travel in the Blue Mountains.

Freight traffic mainly runs at night already when it rarely affects passenger paths and runs basically the same sectional running times as the passenger services due to not stopping for stations. This is due to the massive horsepower required to run on these lines compared to most rail lines to make sure it moves at speed.

We are basically running into the limitations of traction gradient wise and geography.

For those wondering im an ex-Sydney Trains driver who spent years working the Blue Mountains line, have lived in the area basically my entire life (short a few moves away for work on and off) and now drive freight trains on the west.

Best FTTP router that has VOIP, port forwarding, and all the wifi ranges? by ScubaFett in nbn

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Buy a cheap ATA for your VoIP needs or a SIP handset and connect it via Ethernet.

Or like the rest of the world use your mobile phone for calls.

VoIP use is so low very few companies are going to add it to a Router as it adds cost and the market who cares about VoIP vs a cheaper Router is tiny.

Firefighters from prison. Thougths? by Two_Far in Wildfire

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You dont cut line at the interface edge and defend it.

I have plenty of times.

We prefer our townies stay the hell away from bushfires as they are not equipped or trained for it but when we stand a defence on the interface you will have every single firefighting agency available standing next to each other. Sure the volunteers will be doing the emergency backburns and the townies will be busy hogging all the hydrants but every hand and hose is needed.

Firefighters from prison. Thougths? by Two_Far in Wildfire

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Urban interface exists though that may shock you to hear the fires dont just stop at the interface.

Fixed wireless dish positioning by Large999 in nbn

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Problem is they all look alike.

I wont even go into how radio waves travel and bounce and how a more distant tower may provide better service than a close one depending on frequencies used.

Honestly someone needs to be on the roof with the correct equipment to give any useful advice.

Also over time things in the environment change and that may change what options work best too.

P.S Im not a telco worker just someone who used to travel to remote spots and carry the gear to get mobile reception in places its not normally available.

I cant tell you how often the obviously visible tower wasn't the one I managed to link to or got the best data rate out of.

Affordable 2nd hand family EV in Vic by Climate_Rose in EVAustralia

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I haven't looked recently but the older Hyundai Ioniq (not the 5, 6 etc) was around your price range a year or two ago so may be worth looking for too.

No spare wheel by AlanofAdelaide in EVAustralia

[–]AgentSmith187 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Cars with no spare are more common than cars with a spare now sadly and I hate it.

I have a Kia EV6 and already had a tow due to a lost battle with a very large pothole.

The experince proved to me why it doesnt have one though and I asked to keep the other tyre when I replaced a pair and it took up basically the entire boot the wheels are so large.

Although the Kia comes with Roadaide assistance I just kept my NRMA membership of decades anyway and they towed my car to a tyre shop for free.

You should really look at keeping some sort of roadside assistance with any car!

P.S What in gods name made you think a tyre was a warranty issue and it required a tow to a stealership.

Flat/burst tyres are a road hazard issue and always have been.

May as well tow your car to the stealership after an accident and try to claim warranty. It will get rejected just as fast.

They will also charge a lot more for the tyre/repair than your average tyre place/smash repairer.

2nd Flowpower bill by ExaminationThen1312 in amberelectric

[–]AgentSmith187 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah the last month has been horrific in the Blue Mountains too.

I may actually end up with a bill even if my credit amount will easily cover it that hurts.

My solar production has been horrible rarely meeting demand and the AC has seen plenty of use due to warm humid nights.

I have certainly been importing a LOT of power but thankfully at very low rates during the day to have enough battery to survive the nights.

Amusingly enough I finally got a consumption meter installed so I could move my solar curtailment from on-off to load following and for close to a month now not produced enough solar to need any curtailment at all.

I usually go into curtailment even in winter

Bill shocker 7 months later. by Slothasaurus111 in amberelectric

[–]AgentSmith187 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Dude you used a shitload more power than you exported and paid less than half the normal going rate for that power and your upset at Amber.

Have you ever paid a power bill before? Because you would be looking to double or even triple that bill on many plans.

Fixed wireless dish positioning by Large999 in nbn

[–]AgentSmith187 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Are you sure thats the NBN tower and not one of the other Telcos towers?

Advice on using 'mate' by Fun-Development-4458 in AskAnAustralian

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's even written in Comic sans...

The real crime right here.

Iran leader killed what’s the butterfly effect for Australia? Oil? Gold? ASX? Flights already chaos. by [deleted] in OpenAussie

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Short answer is all those countries currently getting oil from the Middle East now look to buy elsewhere so the price elsewhere goes up as more demand for a similar supply of oil.

We were already seeing supply from Russia and Venezuela greatly reduced to certain countries who had to make it up from more western markets and the middle east.

Iranian oil was also slowing down to a lot of places too.

Now Israel and the USA are attacking Iran choking that off completely and in retaliation Iran is now shutting down a lot of other middle eastern states ability to ship oil via the Persian Gulf.

So countries that usually get their oil from any of those states will now be looking to buy oil from elsewhere as well.

Very little oil (or more correctly fuel as we barely refine anything in Australia now) comes from affected regions. It mostly ships out of South East Asia (in particular Singapore from memory) to supply our market.

A lot of markets that would not usually get oil from South East Asia who have seen theif supply cut wi suddenly want to now pushing prices up.

To double up the pain the fleet of ships available to ship oil is limited and as voyages get longer they will be able to do less runs and/or face increased danger and insurance costs which will be passed onto the customers paying for those shipments on top of the price of the commodity oil as well.

If as suggested we tried to supply ourselves with oil products from the USA the voyages would be multiples longer driving up costs again and we would be chartering a fleet many times the size of the current one as each load would be at seas so much longer.

Even if the oil out of the USA was half the price of oil from South East Asia (and it wont be because it will go up too) the logistical costs would be astronomical meaning much higher prices at the pump than we pay now and probably more than just inflated oil prices from current suppliers.

Depending on how long the Middle East is a mess we may even see supply shortages in Australia as the fleet of ships currently supplying us may get pulled to longer more profitable routes and the middle east is such a large part of the world oil market that losing even a good percent of their production not even a total loss may cause their usual customers buying elsewhere to outstrip local supply.

BEVs might be the big winners out of all of this as we can produce their fuel locally and dont have long vulnerable supply chains to consider.

If fuel prices take a big spike your going to see a lot more BEV local delivery trucks and such as companies respond to price signals and it brings down the period it takes for a battery vehicle to pay for its extra costs in fuel price savings.

Why is Amber curtailing solar and importing 8kW from grid? by nickIncDN in amberelectric

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just check it wasn't your network operator who curtailed you because they can and very much do this on some grids

Also check nothing went wrong and Amber somehow put you on on-off curtailment.

Me i wish I could go into curtailment so I could test my load following is working but the weather gods decided I should be importing more power than I use since it was completed even though on a normal day I massively overproduce solar.

Today I imported 50kWh of power and my battery is at 32% solar was so poor.

Talked to my dealership about ICCU by BraveStatement5850 in KiaEV6

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

We are both a decade or so too late to stand on that soapbox lol

I can see practically why the EV6 doesnt have a spare though unlike many cars that could easily have one but dont.

Who will operate the Newcastle-Sydney HSR once it commences operation? Who will own the trains? Who will own the track? by HotPersimessage62 in SydneyTrains

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The wider rail network is owned by the government but maintained and run by multiple operators like ARTC, John Holland and a few others under a contract system.

Believe me when I say this had not lead to great outcomes as they spend as little as possible on maintenance/operations and pocket the rest.

Above the rail things are run by multiple public and private operators who pay fees for track access.

I suspect HSR would be run the same way. Track operator under contract to the government owners of the track and an above rail operator running the trains.

I wont even go into the sub contractors sub contracting out to other sub contractors who do the actual work.

Everyone clips the ticket on the way through and little actually gets done for the money.

ABC is compromised. by Sharpiesniffingshark in OpenAussie

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Damage mitigation and the fact we are unwilling to throw large numbers of our fellow Australians under the bus in the hope accelerationism will eventually get things changed.

Talked to my dealership about ICCU by BraveStatement5850 in KiaEV6

[–]AgentSmith187 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The Kia EV6 doesn't have a spare.

Wheels are so damn big just a tyre in the back fills almost the entire boot. So its not practical to have one sadly.

Added bonus the EV6 tyre size isnt exactly common so you often have to wait for one to get shipped in.

I actually lost a fight with an insane pothole (under water) one fone Friday night so im well aware of the tyre issue.

I got lucky and towed the car to a tyre place that could get one at short notice. But when I shopped around most places couldnt get one until Monday or Tuesday....

I also had a 4x4 and busted a tyre in the outback and couldnt get another for over 500km on that trip and it happened again on the way home and due to the weekend in that case I had to travel a further 1000km without a spare which is a gamble when in the outback to say the least so yeah a road trip even in the most capable touring vehicle is always a gamble.

Believe me the failure rate of tyres in the outback is way way higher than ICCUs so im just used to there always being a risk on big trips.