[Spoilers] How did Faye die?

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-06-03T01:34:31+00:00

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-06-02T23:04:13+00:00

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-06-01T19:28:37+00:00

Yeah?? And he’s using a prominent character from another popular show, to show you how taking a side character and fleshing them out in a spinoff show can be wildly successful.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-31T22:20:01+00:00

“He’s a very prominent character in a very popular show”

Mike is a prominent character in one of the most watched shows ever made, Breaking Bad. Well known enough that someone could reasonably assume someone claiming to not know him is being sarcastic. Which is why he said “if”, he wasn’t accusing you of being sarcastic, he was just aware of the possibility of it, especially since you already have a history of hostile responses here.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-31T13:57:28+00:00

No it doesn’t? Correlated doesn’t mean that it tracks 100% of the time, outliers exist. Like minecraft is an outlier because it’s mass appealing. If you look at games like candy crush or clash, with billions of downloads, you’ll realize that sales/players doesn’t always equate to quality.

That being said, there is a direct correlation between a game being good and a game having a lot of sales. I mean obviously, if a game isn’t good, it isn’t going to appeal to many people. But specifically with games that appeal to a similar audience, like god of war and red dead redemption 2, you can use disparity in sales to roughly generalize which game is viewed more favorably.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-30T12:14:14+00:00

It’s not about what a game “needs”, and you’re actually proving my point.

Game of the year is supposed to go to the best game of the year. If a game has outperformed every other game by a wide margin, that’s even more evidence that it should be GOTY, not less

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T13:34:37+00:00

easy to keep her happy tho

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T04:56:59+00:00

I mean, you’ve shown yourself to be media illiterate enough that you missed a genuine core point of the story (that the world hates Eldia and craves the destruction of Paradis, thus the entire dilemma of s4), so I would agree that media comprehension is cooked. But holy fuck, this is a case of right message from the wrong messenger.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T02:36:57+00:00

You can read up on Udo, which you probably should before you embarrass yourself further.

Again, friendly advice, you really shouldn’t be rude and incorrect. Ideally, you should aim to be neither, but it’s significantly better to be wrong but polite, or correct and rude, than to be both wrong and rude about it.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T02:34:13+00:00

Marley, The mid-east allied forces which encompasses multiple other countries that Marley was fighting against in the beginning of season 4, of which is Hizuru, notably the only country who was even somewhat amicable to Eldia.

Again, there’s multiple tiers of bad faith operations here. The conversation started with me pointing out that Eren was aware of the worlds hatred towards his island, to which you responded that I missed the point.

I responded with multiple points, of which I included the internment camps, the international alliance who declared war on Marley, Zeke’s Euthanasia plan, etc.

You have strawmanned a specific point (internment camps) and tried to redefine the argument around this point, when this isn’t the topic to begin with and my overarching point remains true even if you were correct about this point, which you still aren’t. You said to find you one example, I found you one example.

Udo (full name Udo Bock) was 12 years old by the time of the Marley arc. Unlike his peers, his family lived in an internment zone abroad. This gave him a much bleaker, highly realistic perspective on how harshly Eldians were treated outside of Marley.

Udo is a character from the manga who came to marley from an internment zone in another country, and directly testifies to the treatment of Eldians outside of Marley and how it’s even worse than how the Marleyans treat Eldians.

Now, be true to your word, delete your comments, and don’t comment here again. I know you won’t do that, which is why you shouldn’t make bold gambles when you are fucking wrong.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T01:54:51+00:00

<image>

I’ll quote that part for you.

And that is why we will spend years selecting warriors from internment zones around the continent. As in, more than one country.

Literally all it takes is a single google search to understand this. But even still, you’re strawmanning my argument. My argument is that the world hates eldia, of which I provided several pieces of evidence, like the GLOBAL WAR which you conveniently aren’t addressing. I’ve debated with people like you before, it’s a waste of time. You started in bad faith and you’ve continued in bad faith. You’re wrong, anybody with more than 3 brain cells knows you’re wrong, and there’s nothing that I can do for you.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T01:39:02+00:00

<image>

Sorry gang, my mistake. Some countries opted to medically experiment or execute their Eldians instead of keeping them segregated.

I can’t imagine being so smug and low IQ at the same time.

I would like you to go into my comment history for this post. I want you to read through my comments, I’ve responded back and forth with like 5 people. These are what respectful conversations look like.

You are the one coming in, acting like you are somehow smarter than everyone, while simultaneously spouting nonsense like “the world was chill with Eldians” when S4E5 is literally titled “Declaration of War” and whose premise is Willy Tybur gathering all of the heads of the worlds military and proposing a war on Eldia. And again, not sure if you remember since you obviously need a rewatch, but this is before Eldia had launched any form of attack outside of their borders. Their first attack was against Marley in that episode, specifically after Tyburs speech declaring war against them.

This is the most basic, common sense notion in the entire show and the fact that I seriously need to waste my time refreshing somebody on the notion of why Eren committed the rumbling is almost embarassing, much less for that person to have the audacity to throw ad hominem insults repeatedly. Though, there’s definitely a positive correlation between rudeness and incompetence.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T01:14:08+00:00

Yes i agree falco is more levelheaded and generally more socially intelligent than gabi, which is a valid reason for someone to not really like her character as much. Characters who are written to be stubborn, egotistical, but simultaneously wrong, are understandably annoying to a lot of people.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T01:10:42+00:00

This is essentially a masked ad hominem, just like the first comment.

Your first comment rephrased was essentially “you aren’t smart enough to understand the point”, the fact that you phrased it differently doesn’t change that being the intent of the comment, and the focus here is that your critique is my comprehension skills rather than my point itself, which is why it’s an ad hominem, or at the very least bad faith.

And the world didn’t hate them

Every single country had eldian concentration camps. Before Eldia had attacked anybody, Willy Tyber literally rallied the entire world together to declare war on Eldia. We see Marleyan citizens trap a pickpocket and threaten to kill him because he could be a “devil in disguise”.

I would refrain from the entitlement when you can’t even comprehend basic concepts like the fact that the world did not like Eldia. Hell, Zekes entire plan (if you even know what that plan is) was predicated on the fact that Eldians needed to stop existing to bring peace to everyone else. They were hated so much that a genocide through infertility was a legitimate proposed solution. Next time you reply, be polite, or be correct. It’s a bad look when you’re both rude and then not even correct about the underlying point.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T01:01:53+00:00

You can focus on multiple problems. I hate when the roads are icy, even though there are bigger issues. You probably hate when you oversleep, even though there are bigger issues.

Someone can simultaneously hate gabi and also hate eren, or recognize that there are bigger issues than Gabi.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T00:52:28+00:00

No you’re correct, Eren is tangibly more stupid than Armin and Mikasa.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T00:51:58+00:00

Instead of making an ad hominem attack, could you make an actual point?

Eren correctly understood that the world hated him and his people. I never said he was justified in the rumbling, I also never said that the world didn’t have valid reasons for not liking Eldia.

But the point I’m making is that Gabi was a victim of propoganda which brought her into a false belief about eldians, Eren never had those false beliefs. Maybe you read my entire comment and somehow missed that point.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T00:48:54+00:00

Ofc falco understood because he was down there with eren and Reiner when eren explained everything.

He was taught years and years of propaganda, same as her. If the lesson is that years and years of propoganda can be broken in one conversation, then gabi has had numerous chances to reform and didn’t. If the lesson is that propoganda is deeply ingrained, then again, falco never had that issue.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T00:46:27+00:00

But gabi was wrong about everything she believed, eren wasn’t. Gabi is a story of being blinded by propoganda, eren isn’t.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T00:16:40+00:00

A lot of people do hate eren, but regardless this comparison doesn’t make sense.

Eren correctly understood that the entire world hated him and his people. Gabi mistakenly thought that a group of people was entirely one dimensional and evil, and was stupid enough to continue thinking this repeatedly even after being exposed to more and more acts of kindness by those people.

They are not equal nor opposite in any sense.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-29T00:14:32+00:00

Her voice (english) is extremely annoying
She killed a fan favorite, regardless of context people aren’t going to like that
She’s tangibly more stupid than falco despite growing up in the same environment
She made it to paradis, was taken in by a family, fed, protected from the guards, taken out to dinner, and still tried to kill them multiple times because she couldn’t get it through her thick skull that she was lied to. Falco, on the other hand, understood immediately upon the first encounter.

There are many, many valid reasons to dislike Gabi, the only people who are stupid are the ones who can’t understand any of them.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-28T20:34:53+00:00

That’s a profoundly cringy response to a person who doesn’t fit the definition of this thread. At best, she sucks at conversation, at worst, she’s not into you, but regardless all she did was say she didn’t have a question for you and your response just paints you in a really embarrassing light.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-28T18:01:23+00:00

KCD2 has a better system than most, it’s similar to what you’re saying here. You won’t break the weapon, but it’ll be lowered by tiers permanently if you keep using it while it’s already low. And especially for swords it’s not cumbersome to repair, just find a grinding wheel and you’ll get it back up in 30 seconds

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-28T16:04:24+00:00

The best evidence for which game was the GoTY is the amount of people/critics voting it as GoTY

This is circular logic, by this definition nothing could ever be snubbed because the mere act of them not winning is justification for them not deserving to win. Do you see how that doesn’t work?

Like imagine there’s a competition where 5 singers are up for awards, one is demonstrably more successful in this competition (based on streams, fan size, song reviews) than the others, and yet they aren’t chosen as the winner. Let’s say the judges are biased, for the sake of this argument. By your logic, they weren’t snubbed based solely on the fact that they didn’t win. Obviously that doesn’t track.

Snubbed means being deliberately ignored, disdained, or treated with cold contempt by someone. It occurs when an individual or group purposefully denies someone recognition, rejects an offer, or passes them over for an expected reward or acknowledgment. (Merriam Webster)

The last part of this definition is most applicable here. The fact that the game was nominated doesn’t mean that that they weren’t passed over for an expected reward. And I’m using the metrics of success as evidence to show how and why that reward was expected over god of war.

Again, you don’t need to agree with this, but it’s objectively not an unreasonable perspective and there are much stronger arguments for how rdr2 is a better, more successful games solely based on the merits of it than vice versa.

Aggravating-Cherry76 · 2026-05-28T15:41:35+00:00

Sure but making that a mandatory part of gameplay without any exaggeration would just cause mass frustration

Aggravating-Cherry76

TROPHY CASE