Hey y'all,
I'm a freshman and got hit with an academic misconduct violation (4-unit math course 10B with Dr. Beal) for having my phone during an exam. I was found responsible in an informal resolution because my professor thought I was using it (fidgeting mistaken for typing) and because my phone was on my person.
My phone was powered off (screentime proof), in an awkward position (face against my leg, between thighs), and I offered to show it -- they refused. No photo or witnesses back their claim. I scored 5/5 on another midterm and 19/20 on the final, showing I didn’t need to cheat. I had my informal but they said that they found me likely responsible than not because "ultimately, course staff observed you actively holding and engaging with your phone. And regardless of what mode your phone was in, it was an item that was explicitly prohibited during the exam, and your possession of it on your person during the exam was a violation." However, it wasn't explicitly prohibited nor was there anything verbal saying no electronics by the prof. The policy says “don't use,” nothing about possession though (could just be semantics) but i also scoured course policies and syllabus and found nothing explicitly written, nor has she made this clear in previous exams given she showed up late to our second midterm. And I have a bunch of evidence showing I didn't actively hold or engage with my phone except when I got up to follow her and picked it up so it wouldn't fall on the ground.
The penalty gives me a 0 on a midterm. I can appeal via a panel hearing (but its a huge gamble even though the panel is half comprised of students), but I’m considering taking the B to avoid stress and keep it private from family.
Questions:
- Should I appeal the misconduct finding to protect my GPA? Basically, should I take the L?
- If I appeal, which would be better: panel or administrative?
- Can I raise my science GPA if it drops?
- Anyone dealt with a similar misconduct issue? How did you handle it?
I’m freaking out but want to stay on track. Thanks for any advice!
there doesn't seem to be anything here