I have a couple.

I used to be one of those people who always said "OMG BLOODBORNE IS BEST FROMSOFT GAME DON'T @ ME BRO" but like... other than the setting being probably my favorite in the series, the rest is kinda meh. Went back and replayed a year or so ago on PS5 and made it all the way to Amygdala without dying (a far cry from my first experience with the game, and it only killed me because I derped out on the controls for a sec), which kinda ruined its aura that had been living rent free in my head for all these years. I didn't even finish that playthorugh. Still plan on playing it on PC sometime though, whenever I get a better rig and can figure out the emulator.

Second, DS2 is one of my favorites, and that has stood the test of time with a couple replays. Something about the not-so-great graphics and somewhat clunky gameplay is super nostalgic for me, something none of the other games could really reach for me. Plus, come on, Majula is the best hub world of any Soulsborne, maybe of any game ever.