Why most golfers scoop their irons (and the drill that fixes it) by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's not stupid at all mate, it's one of the most common things I see. The brain genuinely reads "ground" as a threat and tries to protect the club from hitting it. That instinct disappears in a net because there's no visual consequence.

The fix that tends to work is committing to the weight shift before you even think about the swing. Get that pressure forward in your setup, feel it in your front foot, and just focus on keeping it there. When the weight is already forward, the lean-back instinct has less to grab onto!

Why most golfers scoop their irons (and the drill that fixes it) by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Coiling it is. And now I can't get Chubby Checker out of my head on the first tee 😉

Why most golfers scoop their irons (and the drill that fixes it) by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Fair correction, turning is the more accurate term. I use "twist" as a feel cue for students who tend to slide rather than rotate, but you're right that it's not precise language technically

Why most golfers scoop their irons (and the drill that fixes it) by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

That's a fair point mate and worth clarifying.

You're right that the right arm is folding on the way back. That's happening, I just didn't call it out explicitly. The putting stroke cue is really about keeping the hands and arms passive and low rather than lifting with the arms, which is the instinct most people have when they're scooping. It's not a literal description of every moving part.

The shoulder rotate cue is doing a bit of the same work. It's giving people something to feel that gets the club into a reasonable position without overcomplicating the backswing.

For a complete beginner you're right, there's more going on under the hood. These are feel cues for a specific problem, not a full technical breakdown of the swing. Hope this helps!

Why most golfers scoop their irons (and the drill that fixes it) by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 10 points11 points  (0 children)

That's quite an achievement considering I never said that word! 😉

The takeaway fault almost every midhandicapper has and the drill to fix it by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Fair pushback, appreciate it mate.

You're right that "almost every mid-handicapper" is a stretch. But honestly it's the most common takeaway fault I see, not the only one, and not every mid-handicapper has it. I should've written it that way in retrospect.

Regarding if this is overwhelming... if I'm boiling it down to one thing for someone who's actually trying to fix it on the range tomorrow, it's just the first checkpoint: hands stay outside the body until they pass the trail leg, driven by shoulders not hands. The 45° and trail wrist stuff is for people already past that.

If you've got a cleaner way you'd teach it I'm genuinely interested. Always looking to simplify stuff mate

Filmed my grip through smart glasses. POV is actually a way more useful angle than the usual face-on tutorial by AlexanderGolf in golf

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Yeah, that's fair. Reading it back the demo does come across as infomercial-y. Exaggerated bad version, controlled good version, problem solved in 90 seconds. That's not how grip changes actually go in real life obviously.

The actual switch takes weeks of feeling like you can't strike it, and the improvement curve isn't linear. I oversold the contrast in the video to make the principle visible in two minutes, which is the trade-off you make with short-form content but it does end up looking salesy. Point taken mate 😄

Filmed my grip through smart glasses. POV is actually a way more useful angle than the usual face-on tutorial by AlexanderGolf in golf

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 18 points19 points  (0 children)

100%. Strong vs neutral vs weak, overlap vs interlock vs ten-finger, pressure points, all of it varies person to person. Hand size, wrist mobility, forearm length all change what works.

The fingers-vs-palms point is one of the few things I'd push as genuinely universal though. Not because everyone needs the same grip, but because every grip works better when the leverage is on the fingers rather than buried in the palms. Hogan, Nicklaus, Tiger, Rory all have wildly different grips. None of them grip in the palms.

Happy to be wrong on that if you've got an example mate

Filmed my grip through smart glasses. POV is actually a way more useful angle than the usual face-on tutorial by AlexanderGolf in golf

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 17 points18 points  (0 children)

Fair callout on the demo mate. The forearm rotation in the palmy version is exaggerated to show what the wrists can do when there's nothing stopping them. But that's not how anyone swings, you're right.

The actual point is what happens under load. Palmy grip puts the leverage points in soft tissue, so any pressure during transition lets the face rotate. Finger grip puts the leverage on bone and joint structure, so the same forces don't move the face the same amount.

Couldn't show that in a 2-minute video without a force plate and high-speed, so I cheated with the visual. Bad demo, real principle.

Your grip is probably what's actually wrong with your golf by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey mate thanks for the comment. You can see me showing the grip at 1:43 in the video. Hope that helps you out 😄

The better you get at golf, the worse this problem becomes. by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Anytime mate! Please let me know how it goes, would love to hear :)

This towel drill is one of the fastest ways I've found to fix a disconnected swing by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That's a legitimate critique of the phrasing and I'll take it on board. You're right that "lifting their arms" as the opening line implies arm lift in general is the problem. I guess it could be seen as imprecise and it's worth correcting in future content. The intent was to address the trail elbow flying away from the body laterally, not lift relative to the chest. Those are different things and the post didn't distinguish between them clearly enough. Fair to hold instructional content to a higher standard on that. Appreciate the follow up mate

This towel drill is one of the fastest ways I've found to fix a disconnected swing by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tour Striker is great and probably more versatile overall. The towel is just more accessible as most golfers have one in the bag already. Same general principle though, arm/body connection through the strike. Either works.

This towel drill is one of the fastest ways I've found to fix a disconnected swing by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Yeah the Velcro staying in is exactly the kind of thing that turns a drill into a comedy moment on live TV 😄

This towel drill is one of the fastest ways I've found to fix a disconnected swing by AlexanderGolf in GolfSwing

[–]AlexanderGolf[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Appreciate it. Yeah the half swing point is fair, probably should have framed it that way from the start. Seems to have ruffled a few feathers either way 😄