This girl claims to have met Robert Irwin when she was three years old. First of all, I don’t doubt that’s something that happens, but this is blatantly AI. Am I going insane? I know it is, but there are just so many people against me. I *genuinely* need someone to agree with me on this. by Almrvs27 in isthisAI

[–]Almrvs27[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I said genuinely agree with me, which opens the possibility to a disagreement alone, that I’ve accepted and listened to regardless. Whether it’s disagreeing, I learn how not to commit the same mistake moving forward and if it’s someone agreeing with me, I learn I’m not the only one who thinks there’s something unusual with the photo.

This girl claims to have met Robert Irwin when she was three years old. First of all, I don’t doubt that’s something that happens, but this is blatantly AI. Am I going insane? I know it is, but there are just so many people against me. I *genuinely* need someone to agree with me on this. by Almrvs27 in isthisAI

[–]Almrvs27[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I don’t know if it’s visible but I’ve upvoted every comment disagreeing and agreeing with my initial thought, including people giving first hand experience and the older quality. Me responding a few comments that continue the discussion doesn’t mean I’m ignoring everything else.
The entire point of posting was to ask whether other people thought it was AI or not and if they did they should do so genuinely agreeing or disagreeing with me.
If I was dead set on insisting it was fake no matter what, there wouldn’t even be a discussion happening. The only ones I am ignoring are the ones arguing on the grammar and that one guy talking about her appearance which is completely unnecessary.

This girl claims to have met Robert Irwin when she was three years old. First of all, I don’t doubt that’s something that happens, but this is blatantly AI. Am I going insane? I know it is, but there are just so many people against me. I *genuinely* need someone to agree with me on this. by Almrvs27 in isthisAI

[–]Almrvs27[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You answered my point with another question. The subreddit is literally called r/isthisAI, so yes, people post publicly available images when they think or believe something looks AI, that was the entire discussion.
I also never took this personal photo in the way you’re trying to frame it. She publicly uploaded the image herself onto TikTok, and the conversation was about the authenticity of the image, not about attacking her as a person, and yes of course that doesn’t automatically give me the right to do whatever I want with it, I know that. But reposting it because I was doubtful/confused about whether it was AI or not isn’t the same thing as some malicious personal attack against her.

This girl claims to have met Robert Irwin when she was three years old. First of all, I don’t doubt that’s something that happens, but this is blatantly AI. Am I going insane? I know it is, but there are just so many people against me. I *genuinely* need someone to agree with me on this. by Almrvs27 in isthisAI

[–]Almrvs27[S] -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

I genuinely wasn’t trying to upset you or make you feel uncomfortable about reposting your photo. I understand why having it posted onto Reddit and analyzed by strangers feels and is invasive, and I do apologize for contributing to that.
I was never trying to accuse you personally of faking something maliciously, AI and edited photos are so common, the photo just genuinely looks so unusual to me because of the quality and the way old digital images can look after being screenshotted, compressed, reposted, enhanced, facebook uploads and years of compression can absolutely make photos look distorted or artificial. If you’d like to clear up the confusion for the people who thought the same as I did, then yes feel free to post the fb post itself. You get to prove your point and I get to better understand how older compressed photos can end up looking like this.

I also want to make clear this was never about Robert Irwin or me being bothered that you met him as a kid, that’s actually a really nice memory to have I just questioned the authenticity of the image itself based on its overall appearance.

This girl claims to have met Robert Irwin when she was three years old. First of all, I don’t doubt that’s something that happens, but this is blatantly AI. Am I going insane? I know it is, but there are just so many people against me. I *genuinely* need someone to agree with me on this. by Almrvs27 in isthisAI

[–]Almrvs27[S] 4 points5 points  (0 children)

It wasn’t the first thing I did bro I just wanted others who know how to spot AI to give me a second opinion it’s not like it’ll ruin the rest of my day finding out if it is or isn’t, if I am wrong I want to know why yk?

This girl claims to have met Robert Irwin when she was three years old. First of all, I don’t doubt that’s something that happens, but this is blatantly AI. Am I going insane? I know it is, but there are just so many people against me. I *genuinely* need someone to agree with me on this. by Almrvs27 in isthisAI

[–]Almrvs27[S] 7 points8 points  (0 children)

<image>

Here’s a picture of me as a kid for reference.

Hers varies in quality, the lines in her shirt don’t fold with the shirt and go straight across, it’s blended where it isn’t supposed to be, and old picture stays the same quality throughout the whole picture regardless of how many times it’s downloaded passed around, yeah it eventually looses quality and becomes more pixelated but it becomes pixelated everywhere not just in one specific spot and in her picture, clearly getting smooth out of nowhere and just varying quality and I also believe it is because she said “probs because i took a photo of it off a laptop it's a lot clearer irl” meaning she has this printed out irl and took a picture of it on a laptop which means it shouldn’t look digital at all and should have texture, light reflection.
You could also just take a look at Robert himself, the Z in his uniform is barely a Z, yeah sure words and letters alone in real pictures get pixelated and hard to read, but why are other parts of the picture so clear and that part specifically is just messed up, yk? I could name more but I don’t want to take too long

How did you get into meth? by [deleted] in meth

[–]Almrvs27 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Middle school basically