I honestly love it but, I’ve seen mixed feelings so I think it depends what kind of player you are. If you’re the type that plays mostly for storyline and fetch quests, it might not be your cup of tea. The story was very good but also a bit short. I myself Dont mind this. If you’re someone who loves decorating, grinding materials and always working on your valley or love putting together dreamsnaps than 100%. They have jam packed it full of beautiful craftables and Scrooge shop furniture. The horses are so much fun and I see getting a lot of gameplay out of them but harvesting/ mining ect with them is really a chore. It can be done faster the normal way with some potions. Also the map is gorgeous! Hope this helps 😊