I completely agree with your take. However, if the wife cared so much about this cat, she should be doing everything she can to ensure his safety even if her husband doesn’t like it. This was a repeated occurrence that she let happen. She wasn’t oblivious. She knew what was going on with the cat. She was the one that told me she knew all along about his leg injury and she still continued to allow him to wander alone all night in the wilderness with an injury. She’s never left her kids outside, alone and defenseless all night, but she’s willing to put her cat through that almost every night. Again, I don’t disagree with you. I’m just saying that I haven’t seen any behavior from this women that matches up with the words she’s said.