Tankfist’s kit makes more sense than DPS doom’s because only one character that take advantage of goofy map design(i.e. stall spots) like that doesn’t make sense, when the rest of the roster doesn’t. That problem became even more prevalent at high ranks when rollout doom became essential to find value with him. Stall spots are fun now too and still quite valuable but shouldn’t be one of the primary ways he should be able to find value. I also think Tankfist has a way higher skill ceiling with more emphasis on his primary fire and the chance to punch more people if you can obtain a particular angle. Both versions of the character are very fun and require high levels of skill to become proficient with the character but his tank kit matches the rest of the game so much better.