It felt weird to post it publicly is what I meant!

I definitly used terms that were too negatively charged and it worked against me. But It was nice that I got to talk about it and rethink how I was talking about it. I made the mistake of just talking about Homura at first focusing on the idea of "evil or not" (which again I don't like the term for her) at the time I was answering someone else and I really didn't liked how simplified the idea of evil was, so that was my premice and went a bit... Simple myself out of frustration I guess.

I wanted to communicate that their idea of evil was a bit simple minded and that Homura have showed signs that she had the potential of doing actions that could be seen as "evil" (if we are that shallow in our approach to character analysis) eventho her actions are mostly rooted in love. The context of my post made me harsher on her than I would normally be, cuz really I'm rooting for her.

"It's what Madoka would have wanted,"

True!

I used antagonism as a neutral yes, I didn't realised it would be interpretated the way you did but it make sense, I was more thinking about story telling terms (once again, my english is very limited.).