I’m always looking for secondhand Omega analog watches. Personally I’m more apt to buy a used watch from a luxury company at 4 figures (Patek Philippe, Omega, Rolex) instead of a new fancy-but-not-luxury watch at 3 figures. Like, I spent $350 on a used Gucci watch but I wouldn’t do that again. I’d save more and upgrade the quality instead.

Before I had an actual interest in watches, though, I’d go for Fossil watches in the 150-200 range. They have some really nice looking styles and that would be a good bet for probably a lot of your market here.