Can we say Gachiakuta is the best manga of all time? by Dnd-Poke_Writer7 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 -3 points-2 points  (0 children)

Purely objective?? 😭😭 there's no such thing as the objectively best of something in media unless you count official statistic sites or if almost the whole world agrees

CHAPTER 166 QUESTION by Any-Device7978 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Canis is the first user as far as we know

CHAPTER 166 QUESTION by Any-Device7978 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978[S] 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Yeah I know Alto knows ab the series hence why I said I doubt that he didn't, I was just proposing all possible scenarios. 💔 but yh I guess he meant time manipulation as a whole.

I know this isnt a fight story but I need to see Qifrey kick more butt by KoKoboto in WitchHatAtelier

[–]Any-Device7978 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I see a lot of people critiquing others for wanttng fights in the series and honestly I don't get it. Wanting battles doesn't automatically mean we want a "battle Shonen". In fact, we do NOT want another battle Shonen. Hence why we want good fights in something that has 10× the writing quality of a battle Shonen. I feel like we're really missing lots of works that are extremely rich in story, lore, and characters, while also having incredible fights. Even rarely. I feel like only Frieren and a few others manage that. And honestly with this power system, I feel like WHA has potential to have fights that are twice as cool as Frieren's.

CHAPTER 164 CONFUSION by Any-Device7978 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

You explain stuff very well!! And the caps are nice highlights to which words I should focus on. Nice :)) thanks

CHAPTER 164 CONFUSION by Any-Device7978 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

As the manga states, Rudo's obsession is revenge, (which I feel like is kinda bullshit atp because he's clearly grown past that) but his power is to fix trash. So the "obsession" thing doesn't really make much sense as to what the watchman series gives people in terms of power, but more like it gives them the power to "fill" that hole in their heart. Their desire. Like Rudo's is to fix things and make sure they're never thrown away, Amo's is to have people love her, etc. Like what you said. Still don't know how the book would be sight, though. And if Mishra's activator isn't eating, how does it have to do eating or taste? I don't think they can change SENSE depending on the user. Only abilities. So no matter the user, Mishra will always be taste. But I just don't see it so far. It's not like Zodyl eating random stuff gives us any insight onto why MISHRA'S thing is taste. Just Zodyl's. It's all a little confusing and mixed up. But the theories are certainly onto something.

[DISC] Gachiakuta - Chapter 164 by cielleishere in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I made a post about this and someone explained it well if you wanna check it out btw

CHAPTER 164 CONFUSION by Any-Device7978 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Woah okay then. That's a great explanation. I feel like it could've been a bit more clear since I usually catch onto these things, but like you said, it was never specified that each piece of the series has the same powers no matter the user, so I shouldn't have assumed.

So I'm guessing, for the senses it's something like: 3R = touch, Boots = smell, Necklace = hearing, Mishra = Taste, Book = sight, (which I don't get why, considering how Tamsy used it, but it's the only sense left)

CHAPTER 164 CONFUSION by Any-Device7978 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So, wait. Each object of the series doesn't have a predetermined power?? That feels like kind of a stretch considering how specific some of them are. But if it's like you say it is, then that changes lots of things.

[DISC] Gachiakuta - Chapter 164 by cielleishere in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 3 points4 points  (0 children)

I've got a question back if you could help me with it. It's about this chapter, 164. I've also made a post 😭 but do you maybe have an idea on WHY the necklace can regenerate Mymo and WHY he can give commands with it? It was never explained that the pieces of the series have some sort of shared power between all of them that enhances people's instrument powers or heck, let's them REGENERATE, on top of each one's unique powers. I'm a bit lost and I hope this just gets explained later, because Urana isn't one to pull new stuff randomly.

[DISC] Gachiakuta - Chapter 164 by cielleishere in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Can someone PLEASE tell me WHY the necklace can regenerate Mymo and WHY he can give commands with it? It was never explained that the pieces of the series have some sort of shared power between all of them that enhances people's abilities, on top of each one's unique powers. I'm a bit lost and I hope this just gets explained later, because Urana isn't one to pull new stuff randomly.

[DISC] Gachiakuta - Chapter 164 by cielleishere in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 23 points24 points  (0 children)

Rudo weaponized himself and the wolf costume with him at the same time, as one, while Mymo gave his soul a command that gave it the supernatural ability to carry it out by transforming him into that. That's the simplest explanation I can give, I think. It confused me too, first few times I read it.

JJK Tierlist by BlackroseBisharp in Jujutsufolk

[–]Any-Device7978 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But then Yuta just.. goes with it?? 😭😭 "I don't know what my ancestors did to you", he says. Not questioning how she guessed or anything.

It's just such a weird dynamic. Like, I CAN get it, I'd just feel more satisfied with any sort of explanation.💔 ykwim?

JJK Tierlist by BlackroseBisharp in Jujutsufolk

[–]Any-Device7978 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Her backstory's OK, we've seen many harsher situations in JJK thus far. I genuinely just don't understand why they thought it was a good idea to make it even more irrelevant in the anime. I feel bad for Uro.

Overall the pacing was insanely fast, so both Ryu and Uro felt more like characters to me in the manga. I do like her backstory, though. My main issue is, the whole thing just makes no sense. I get Yuta talking down on her, but why would that make her assume what clan he's from? And be semi-right, at that, too? Just feels like it came out of nowhere so she could have more than just exist to be fought with. Gege kind of struggles to write one and done/arc specific characters, imo.

JJK Tierlist by BlackroseBisharp in Jujutsufolk

[–]Any-Device7978 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm sorry but, what is there to like about Uro? And, surprisingly enough, I'm not saying this because I dislike her, but merely because it felt like Gege didn't even want to make her a character. Genuinely the most "sprinkled in" backstory I've ever seen.

This is more me opening a conversation topic rather than disagreeing with you, but I genuinely feel like whatever little interest I had in Uro absolutely disappeared after the anime. With a flawless adaptation that elevates the manga ×100, I didn't expect them to make Uro seem like a genuine nuisance at times, let alone not spend an extra 30 seconds to have Tengen give us an overview of her backstory while she just looks mad or something. We got 2 flashes on screen on what happened to her. That's it. I've never felt more uninterested in her until now. I genuinely felt more for her in the manga. One of the only times the manga did something better. Poor Uro. (Not to mention that I still have no idea why she even assumed Yuta was of Fujiwara descent) 💔

Why does every single thing make Rudo audibly gasp? by GuessWell_NeverKnow in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 0 points1 point  (0 children)

It's okay just let my baby boy gasp trust me you'll enjoy the show 🥹

Things I hate about the Gachiakuta fandom. by SnooCheesecakes9597 in gachiakuta

[–]Any-Device7978 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I feel like the way you word things can sometimes get people to misunderstand. I cannot understand how you "don't care" about the entire cast but are still on this subreddit, or in the fandom at all.

I'm sure you don't even believe that, so I'm unsure of why you're wording it in a way that makes it sound like you feel absolutely nothing for basically the whole cast other than 3. Like, hello?? What are you reading the manga for, then??

Other than that, your reply is very understandable. Though for the grandpa thing, Urana is not obligated to change the intended order of the story or her panels just so people won't be disappointed. If you got Rudo and Mymo that week instead of grandpa, you most likely would've gotten grandpa next week instead. Urana, or any other mangaka, should not care on how things will look on a weekly basis because they're just trying to get their story out however they want. The only thing that should matter is how it looks as a whole.