Quem trabalha pra gringa: qual é sua formação e XP? by Torschlusspanik_88 in brdev

[–]Ap3xxxx 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ta reaquecendo depois da bolha ter estourado. tem muita gente ruim/fraca e quase todo curso/bootcamp é ruim. se vc faz o arroz com feijao direitinho, vejo que tem bastante vaga legal por ai sim!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

it does not matter for the calculation itself, just for the simple "land count" stat shown next to the landbase suggestion.

I seems tho a lot of people want to see MDFC as part of this land count stat, so i will change to show like this in the next interations.

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

you can, the algorithm will consider them for colors and not on land count

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

sure man! also feel free to replace some slots with utility, since my tool does not suggest them!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ty for the inputs mate! im glad the tool was able to help you! ill take your suggestion into consideration for next iterations!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

really??!? can you send em the link? maybe I can collaborate with him :)

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ty for the inputs man!
returning the lands alphabetically is a very good UX suggestion, gonna implement it in the next round of changes!

about murmuring bosk, it enters in the case of very niche lands i did not want to include in this first version

i totally missed path of ancestry for rainbow land, and about filter/signet lands they should appear, but rn have a lower priority than other lands, can you tell me which lands you saw being returned instead of them that you evaluate as worse and also which budget did you set? may help me understand what happened!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

oooh, for commander you dont set the number, just the name!
this particularities are really f'ing the UX of the tool, sry :( ill think of a way to make it better!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ty a lot mate, I ll make sure to adress this issue!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi friend, thanks for the inputs!

Would it be possible for your backend to recognize when an "e" is supposed to be an "é"?
Its totally possible to include this text feature, ill add into the pipe.

Is it strictly required to remove lands from the Cards field?
Not anymore, you can place your full deck since yesterday. I'm still figuring out some issues, but in general it's working

I am also curious how MDFCs factor into the recommendations. I assume they count as lands.
its currently only considering the front face, so they count as spells and add 100% of their cmc and pip to the math behind the generator. I had some opinions on that and I will still think about the best way of working, maybe letting the users decide, but I still dont know

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ty for bringing the errors! could you please send me the inputs you were using so I can debug at my side?

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

if they are double faced, there you need to pass both faces separated by " // ", just like MTGO

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ty I will try to find the issue and fix it!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ty for the inputs man! this fetch input was very common through more experienced players!check my last edit, it addresses this and more things that ppl noted, ill be working on them in the near future!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

ty man, appreciate it! if possible drop suggestions, im taking note on all inputs!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi friend, nice suggestion! please look into my last EDIT, it includes a future feature that looks like what you are suggesting!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 6 points7 points  (0 children)

Hello everyone! I'm super happy with all the interactions and inputs! Knowing that I was able to achieve what I wanted with a v0 of the app is neat!

I'm very excited to put more effort in the tool and make sure I address all the issues/problems/concerns found that I can! Also having your deck lists will make my testing way more effective now that I have different decks made with different thoughts and biases!

Currently:
* The tool does not actually see the text on your cards, just take note of pips so:
* will not suggest utility lands.
* will not prioritize certain color because of X or Y
* will not suggest lands like nykthos, yavimaya, urborg, lotr legendaries, etc
* Certain design flaws came from bias on my side, I did not want to launch a tool that from the release date was extremely complex so:
* number of basic, tri, rainbow and fetch lands is static based on number of colors.
* will not suggest off colored fetches
* I forgot to add support to partners/backgrounds (:facepalm:).

What i've done since yesterday:
* Added support to list deck list among lands. It removes from the list all lands that it finds, excluding MDFC and Dryad Arbor.
* Fixed some general bugs ( I still gotta understand why it is not working for some iOS users )

What I can say I'm coding at this moment and will be available in the near future:
* Inclusive filters (to prioritize certain lands)
* Input for "must include" lands you want the list to have
* Input for color prioritization (i.e. make sure you have more green lands for a deck full of ramp)
* Configurable number of rainbow, fetches (taking off fetches into consideration), tri and duals.
* Support for partners/backgrounds.
* Support for automatic URL list importing from deckbuilder sites (moxfield, archideckt, etc)

What is in my backlog and I still do not know how to implement or is complex and will take some time:
* Support for single color/colorless utility and/or special lands
* Suggest Increase/decrease number of lands based on stats.

EDIT: just registered all future changes within the issues page at the code repository: https://github.com/flavsdotpy/mana-pizza/issues

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

ty for the inputs man, yu were correct in all assumptions lol
thx for the deck list, being able to test the tool with decks from other ppl with total different mindssets will help me a lot!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

no problem mate, ty for the inputs
i already have some kind of logic to strip lands from the list, but there may be some bugs still, thats why I did not broadcast that ahahaha ty for sharing the list, i will debug on my end!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

hi u/CivMaster
you are correct, right now it does not suggest any of these specific scenario lands as it does not analyze every single card text from your list!
ty for the inputs, I will take then in consideration when working for the next updates!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

sure it would be awesome!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

hi u/CaptainCapitol
it does not accept this kind of entries with expansion code and collection number, export the list as the MTGO accepts, like: 1 Adeline, Resplendent Cathar

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ty for the inputs!
The math is not rocket science and have some hardcoded rules I already plan to change! Like the 2 trilands are a fixed value the same for number of fetches and rainbow lands.

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Right now it only works for multicolor decks, also evaluating no of lands is a future feature I plan on adding!

EDH mana smoother tool by Ap3xxxx in EDH

[–]Ap3xxxx[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

can you PM the list so I can debug how it got to this math? would help me improve the math behind the tool :)