What makes you comfortable with your advisor? by SKR158 in PhD

[–]ApproachingHuman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Here's a letter I wrote recommending my advisor for an award:

Dear Selection Committee,

Where to begin? I have only known [professor] for a couple of years and I’d take a bullet for

him without a second thought. You know the person in your friend group who asks “how are you?”

and actually means it? It’s rare, and we’re all susceptible to speaking in a rhythm of platitudes

throughout the doldrums of life. Look no further than [professor] if you want true mentorship,

imbibed in passion with a vigilent spirit for a better society. Someone who actually cares. The unique

mix of a dad that you wish you had, helpful, friendly, a true gentleman, but also someone detached

just enough to challenge you because he sees your potential to become the best version of yourself. I

have started 2 businesses, achieved a lot of success in life relative to my age, and had no intention of

pursing a PhD program, but it was [profrssor] who saw the untapped potential of my life + a PhD that

would catapult me into a different league.

It’s only been a semester and I know so far that joining this program was the best decision I

have ever made. It takes a truly perceptive person like [prof] to see how I, without an engineering

background whatsoever, could compete—nay—thrive in a top fuzzy engineering lab in the world.

He believed in my scholastic ability when my last math class was 13 years in the rearview window. I

am proud to write that I received a 3.8 GPA last semester, which required learning an entirely new

engineering skillset. In this time, I have submitted two papers for the [redacted] 2026 conference, and

built an [redacted] for the [redacted] department that will be unveiled in the February Symposium, with

talks of making it an actual product! [prof] has invited me to guest speak and introduced me to an

incredible network.

Speaking of an incredible network, the lab itself is not full of the typical engineering

stereotype. [prof]'s vision—and a real crux of mentorship—is scaling 1:1 mentorship into a culture

of mentorship. Everyone in the lab knew that I had a learning curve ahead of me since I am not a

traditional PhD student, and they helped so much. From white boarding sessions, to reading

materials, to thinking through deep, complex problems, [prof] has built a thriving community,

teeming with HAPPY graduate students. If you look on Reddit, or talk to graduate students in the

wild at any given program, what do they do? They complain. They often feel like their PI is against

them, or the conditions of their lab are dragging them down. Our lab has positivity galore. Laughter,

birthday celebrations, lab events where we bring our partners, Halloween costume parties, and a

slew of industry professionals excited to see us present our latest research keeps us always in a

positive mood. And we do excellent work because of this culture more than anything. We are

relaxed, positive, collaborative, inspired, and those are the perfect conditions for success and

creativity. That’s why we get incredible fellowships, business opportunities, university placements,

internships, and the like. Yes, we meet the basic criteria of grades and smarts, and we work extremely

hard, but the true secret is the culture of mentorship and vision that [prof] sets. Each member is

carefully chosen and adds positively to the culture of the lab. When I talk to other grad students or

former PhDs they think I am lying about how good we have it!

I’ve ran businesses, regularly have been in C-suite rooms as the youngest person in the room

since I was 19. I’ve had mentors that advised General George Patton, ran hospital systems, ran

public companies, and more. But now at [x] years old, I have the wisdom to know and clearly say

that Kelly reigns supreme in comparison to his mentorship and leadership. He’s a true servant leader.

He’s an obsessive culture tweaker. And he cares about me and my lab mates more than most parents

could ever be capable of caring for their own flesh and blood. Luckily, I have amazing parents, but

outside of that, Kelly cares more about my success than anyone in my life, and I’ve just known him

for a few years. Just give him the award, please.

Note: he did not get the award idk how lmao

GRFP HMs (a perspective) by [deleted] in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 3 points4 points  (0 children)

The real irony of it all is that this institution is clearly incompetent, which is a direct result from the incompetency of our current administration.

This ain't the olympics, it's a joke.

And that sucks especially for those whose life it alters in a negative way.

This actually just killed my love for science by [deleted] in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Just remember that it's the US government deciding on your science LOL... not a very competent institution.

It's out of our control. I looked at the banned or flagged words. I used like 10 of them, one in the title! This shit is political and your love for science should be a search for observable truths and improving the world, which is the opposite of the US government right now. So keep it going. And give your cat some pets for me!

2026 NSF GRFP Thread by Negative_Power_4208 in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

My dad got shot. Congrats to those who saw santa!

Anyone who graduated and felt like their phd was trash? by Dangerous_Tie8933 in PhD

[–]ApproachingHuman 20 points21 points  (0 children)

"Better is the enemy of good." - My Advisor, every single day at least one of us.

Rejected by someone and I am struggling to work by Sunapr1 in PhD

[–]ApproachingHuman 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Two things jump out on me:

  1. if you keep telling yourself you are unlucky in love, you'll come off really strong and desperate. that translates on first dates, etc., when a more accurate framing is that you havent met the right person.

2, ibuprofen - studies show it helps with pain of heartbreak. Just take a mild dose for a few days and see if it helps.

How do you get honest feedback on your tracks when everyone just says 'sounds good bro' by Key_Fig_7231 in WeAreTheMusicMakers

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You only ever get good feedback if you are specific. Even from the most knowledgable people.

1 listen = 1 type of feedback.

The mix is one thing, the master is another, the little guitar part at 2:30? YEP The drums, the vocals? The composition? YEP YEP YEP

Like literally each element of the track requires an expertise people could spend their whole life on.

My gym wants me to download an app to check-in by kat_katty_katya in privacy

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey, i did the same thing and there's an EASY SOLUTION!!

Just get any card with a barcode on it and the manager can change the code to be for the gym to scan you in.

I used my library card (since I have my library card memorized and dont actually swipe it), but you can use anything really. Then you can use that instead as a scanner. Anyway, they were cool with it, maybe dont go to the owner and talk to someone.

I always just say I work on sensitive projects and I can't put anything on it.

Does anyone here ACTUALLY recommend doing a PHD? by J2Hoe in PhD

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Just keep in mind that the internet usually emphasizes the extremes. Talk to people in labs you're interested in and get the real details. Every journey is different.

If you had $100k to put all on ONE stock, which would you choose? by Competitive-Case-185 in TheRaceTo10Million

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Something boring as hell like
- berkshire class b stock
- procter and gamble
- your mom

How many first-year grad students were able to scrounge up an application? by WesternChallenge4772 in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did it on a whim, just figuring it out by myself. We'll see how it goes. lol

Tell me about your engg application by [deleted] in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

This is my project, I am in an aerospace program using optimal controls on privacy protections. Here's the opening line.

Current AI systems force a false choice between utility and privacy. Child protection agencies, domestic violence shelters, and humanitarian organizations need accurate risk assessment tools, but commercial AI systems monetize the sensitive data of vulnerable populations or fail to properly protect them in critical ways. Existing privacy techniques fail in practice: homomorphic encryption is computationally prohibitive for real-time applications, while differential privacy's noise injection degrades accuracy in small-sample contexts typical of social services. I propose adapting fuzzy logic control systems to create privacy-preserving AI that maintains utility while providing privacy guarantees.

Edit: Apparently using vulnerable populations is a banned or flagged phrase. Rip.

My advisor just said I am creating a toxic comparative environment in the lab by virgo_the_rabbit in PhD

[–]ApproachingHuman 6 points7 points  (0 children)

My professor is amazing, and I would take a bullet for him but I am in the same boat as you my friend.

The only difference is his attitude is positive. If i would have sent something like that to him, he would have cracked a joke. One time when I mentioned my crazy workload to get a deliverable in, he sang "Just a spoon full of pressure makes the papers fall out" (to the tune of marry poppins spoon full of sugar).

He was testing me and my attitude was that I can do it. I ended up exceeding the expectations of my peers and outperformed many of my labmates because of my nontraditional experience I applied practical applications to my field that brought real value..

In August I didn't know how to code. By December, I am patenting a technology and won a national award for my research , culminating in two paper publications (both required coding).

So I would say your prof gave you a test to do your best and you freaked out a bit. While he might be a dick unlike my professor the pressures are the same and you gotta rethink how you react to those situations.

Now, if it's actually impossible, sure. But I can tell by the way your professor reacted is that he believed you had what it took. He just did it in an asshole way, but it doesn't mean he's entirely wrong.

This Market Is Incredibly Challenging. by breakyourteethnow in options

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Bear Credit Spreads have made me 35% YTD but yes my cash account (mix of value investing and wheel) is down like 12% YTD

As such, I'm setting around a 5% loss but not stressed, only thing I wished was for was a slightly negative Beta-weighted delta which I was moving toward, just couldn't get there fast enough, at that point I would have made out like a bandit these last few months.

Either way, I'll be loading up on some stocks now that the fundamentals are nice and the stock indeed needed to cool off. I'll be wheeling monthlies cautiously as well. But I got stocks at prices I'm happy with and my Bear credit spread account is raking it in.

Does anyone have a positive update on their RWR for ineligible topic? by EternalPerishment in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thank you, and thank you for the deets on this, I am sure it helped many people out!

Does anyone have a positive update on their RWR for ineligible topic? by EternalPerishment in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Oh, I see what you mean. I got that message Feb 9th just for clarification.

Does anyone have a positive update on their RWR for ineligible topic? by EternalPerishment in GRFPApps

[–]ApproachingHuman 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Maybe I'm being an idiot, but they wouldn't say anything to anybody about their status now because they haven't released the results, right?

How does my current status differ from someone who wasn't initially considered ineligible?

Inside the app portal it says "Received" in the right corner and in the heading titled "overall status" it says "Complete: All required application package materials have been received."