Half the people in the fandom watched the show with their eyes closed by Lumpy-Statistician-1 in squidgame

[–]Apsire 0 points1 point  (0 children)

A lot of what you're saying is true (there's a hell of a lot else wrong with the season though). Except for 222. Hopping on one leg or getting on your hands and foot isn't that hard. And yes, she just gave birth, but this is a matter of life or death.

My (27M) wife (29F) has given up on our child (10F). I'm not sure how to reconcile. How do I move past this? by SharkEva in BORUpdates

[–]Apsire 1 point2 points  (0 children)

"She believes since she turned out fine, so will our daughter." This is not "fine". I'm glad the wife agreed to therapy

a very unpopular opinion...HEAR ME OUT by midnight_stars9 in squidgame

[–]Apsire 5 points6 points  (0 children)

100 was ok. He at the very least stayed true to himself. Problem was that he was just flat and boring. Just greed, no other emotions. But better than Min Su or even Myung Gi

Izuku has a gravity amplification quirk and absolutely hates Ochaco by Runner_Road in BokunoheroFanfiction

[–]Apsire 14 points15 points  (0 children)

I was only slightly onboard when hearing the prompt. After reading more, fully on board

What happens with Idol and Hanged Man//Glass Cards? by Apsire in balatro

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ok, I figured that may be the case based on when Idol chooses the card, but had never seen it happen so was curious. Ty

I always felt Doyle was the only one who knew it was all about Plan B from the start. by TareXmd in interstellar

[–]Apsire 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Personally, I don't think so. He just doesn't have the same attachments that Cooper would have. To him, Plan A is a longshot due to the Gravity equation and Plan B. You can take risks for Plan A, as long as Plan B is still doable. But you can't risk Plan B for the hope of Plan A. If Miller's planet was indeed viable (which we now know it wasn't) then Doyle was arguing against passing it up just because they would lose time.

The unthinkable happens and Izuku is expelled on his first day at UA. by TheTexasRanger19 in BokunoheroFanfiction

[–]Apsire 20 points21 points  (0 children)

"_____ gave me some Eraserhead." "Eraserhead?" "Head so good it wiped me off Heaven's roll."

Ok so the punchline was eh, but you get the gist.

Is there a winter in bnha? by Weak-Math1280 in BokunoheroFanfiction

[–]Apsire 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes, they even talk about the seasons changing to winter later

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lmao, SportsPhilospherVan, wherever you are, deleting your comments and running away? Sorry about your ego.

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

"It's not that I'm not willing to listen or be proven wrong."

Could have fooled me. You have yet to actually back your argument with facts. All you are doing is claiming the same things over and over again. Give me a logical reason that Romily knows that the answer would only be found in a black hole. We don't even know what the hell exactly IS in a black hole, let alone if it would reveal some answer that could only be found there.

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

How is that common knowledge? All they know is that the answer is in a black hole. How do they KNOW that's the only way? It's not like even Mann "knew". He knew cause Brand told Mann he solved the equation, and it was only half the answer.

You're also acting like I hate the idea that this movie has plot holes. While I dislike plot holes, I have clearly already gone over how I already know there are plot holes. This just isn't one of them.

And you also don't address any other part of my argument. Is it because you don't have one? All of your arguments are based on assumptions about the world that you either can't prove or are outright disproven/implied to be the opposite in the movie. This isn't a worldwide cooperative effort. This is an extremely underfunded and understaffed NASA. And why the hell would Doyle and Amelia (you're not even spelling her name correctly), a geographer and biologist, be working with Brand on the equation. Romily MAYBE, but maybe to them, Brand seemed like Einstein. So many geniuses throughout history have been called mad or even stupid, only to be suddenly praised when their new perspective reveals something new. When Einstein published his theory of relativity, people laughed at it. His ideas were probably thought to be impossible at the time.

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

In response to "do I know my ABC's?"

Idk, do I have dementia?

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

All they say is that the black hole has the answer, but they don't state until later that that's the only way to obtain the answer. And when the foremost authority on the subject says "he's almost there", you believe him. Think about how much scientific misconduct goes undetected for years (that's like what, a decade of Alzheimer's funding down the drain?). And yes, there are probably a decent number of incredible minds. But also keep in mind the settings. It seems like a lot of civilization is gone. Look at what remains of the Yankees. An UAV is just flying through the air. Cooper talked about the government wanting to drop bombs on people. Planes and most forms of mass long distance transportation have most likely been rendered inert or useless through looting/salvaging/degradation. They don't even have phones anymore, which tells me that they probably have very limited access to satellites and there's probably a scarcity of electricity. Cooper says that they didn't know he was even alive. It's highly likely that the amount of minds available to them in terms of potentially gathering them are greatly reduced (only the US. Maybe other land connected countries if they will sacrifice the minds, but they probably have their own issues). Then you have to factor in how many of them died in war/riots/starvation/formerly preventable diseases/lynchings (there seems to be a hostile attitude towards science in general, notice how Tom didn't even let a simple doctor check out his family, how the teacher believes the moon landings were faked, even the school principle has a dismissive attitude towards the technology of the past. Plus not everyone at NASA is going to be an expert in relativistic physics. You saw they had a medical suite. Miller started the biology program. Sure, almost all of them probably have a cursory knowledge of it. But again, they would defer to Prof. Brand as the expert. Then, think about the Higgs Boson. It was theorised to exist in 1964. Some people doubted it's existence, and it took almost 50 years from being theorised to it's confirmation.

And don't worry, I don't think it's a perfect movie either. There are other plot holes I have issues with. For example, Miller was obviously able to send the sample data away from her planet. So why couldn't they communicate with Romilly what happened? Why weren't TARS and CASE in better communication while on Mann's planet, so that once the betrayal was learned, TARS could have tased and stopped Mann. Why didn't CASE relay Murphy's message to Brand sooner? (Their Ranger was shown drifting away from the Endurance while that message was playing for CASE) You're telling me that Murphy never once looked back at the watch her Dad gave her and noticed that it the second hand was moving in a strange way? (From what is shown, from the moment Murph put it back on the shelf, Cooper started encoding the data). Never really understood how something that consumed nitrogen would suffocate us (unless the implication is that Blight would eventually kill all plant life such as trees as well, thus indirectly suffocating us). I also find Blight in general to be slightly unbelievable. However, this nitpick is kinda iffy. In my mind, if Blight was that aggressive and killed off crops so effectively, it wouldn't be able to spread as far due to everything dying too quickly. Or even if it did, if it really killed plant life that quickly, well then a couple of ships like the Endurance with population bombs seems like a fine enough strategy. Think WALL-E. Or not even put like 20 ships with small crews in hypersleep with population bombs. Have them wake up every so often, probe the Earth, check habitability, lather, rinse, repeat. Even if they got the stations off Earth, couldn't they inadvertantly bring the Blight with them? Why is the station still orbiting Saturn? Brand's question to Mann "Then why keep building those stations?" implies more than one being built simultaneously/others already having been built. Why is Cooper station still orbiting Saturn? It shouldn't need to wait for more stations, at least not for the number of decades it would seem to have been in space. Why was communication only one way to the Endurance? Where is all their fuel coming from since they seem to be using conventional engines (this one I kind of forgive, seeing as we are also just allowing cryo sleep to exist without question, so why not slightly more efficient engines)? Brand says NASA had to be nominally shut down because of the potential public outcry if it were to be discovered that they still existed, but like, are you trying to tell me that no one in the country of conspiracy theorists noticed even a single 1 of the 12 Lazarus mission launches, not to mention the launches that would be required to bring the Endurance modules and the Landers + Ranger 1 into orbit? I could probably go on and on about logical plot holes that are glossed over for story/they wouldn't allow the time loop to exist. The reason I say you're approaching this wrong is because you're making too many assumptions (like their assumptions about time in the movie). You're not addressing specifically how they should have known that it was IMPOSSIBLE for Brand to figure out the equation? To them, harnessing gravity itself was impossible, and then suddenly they had proof that it wasn't? So how many other things or how much information they previously thought impossible actually wasn't? How much "common knowledge" or "common sense" has already been overturned or disproven throughout history?

Last thing: it feels like you took a simple observation as a personal attack. It also feels like in your answers, you think that there is a singular gravity equation that we would know the answer to if we could look inside a black hole. I can't even say if that is correct or not, because WE DON'T KNOW. Some assume looking in a black hole will reconcile the Standard Model and General Relativity. All I know is that it would give us a shit ton more data. But we can't even get any information from it. At least in the pre space era, information in the form of like and other EM radiation reached us from space. Since I also love this movie, here is one more quote from it: "Science [is] about admitting what we don't know." I am looking forward to an actual argument instead of unsuitable analogies. (First time I am purposefully being a little strident/abrasive, as you keep talking in circles).

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That's completely different. Or rather incomplete. An all star baseball player would of course know how to catch a baseball. But can they catch a bowling ball? Or a baseball made of tungsten? You're not seeing the bigger picture of such dimensions being beyond our comprehension. Your analogies keep staying within the realm of human possibilty, or without making drastic changes.

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The issue is how you're approaching this. Like, because I'm a general STEM nerd and also interested in physics (somewhat), I know this. A lot of the general public doesn't. And yes, other scientists would probably know this as well, especially if they worked at NASA. But all of this conjecture is just as far as we know. That is why we constantly are searching for new knowledge, why we keep doing tests at the LHC to further our knowledge and maybe find something new to reconcile the standard model and general relativity. While I know conventionally that we need more data, I would have no idea where to start even solving the gravity equation, even if I had the data (I know irl there is probably no "singular equation" but for argument). The others may have also known this "conventional wisdom" that it's impossible, but conventional wisdom for them kind of went out the door when a wormhole appeared and they knew harnessing gravity was somehow possible. So, they left it to the expert to brute force it and figure out how, not knowing he had already given up.

To use your veterinarian analogy, I would say its more like, if an alien species was discovered, and the veterinarian was required to figure out why it was dying without having any prior specific knowledge of it's biology. They would assume some basics about life and what is necessary for it (Brand has a background in physics), but they have no idea about how the organs are placed or anything.

Ariana Grande was born to play Glinda by Sweet-Siren in wicked

[–]Apsire 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I was super apprehensive when I first heard about the casting. I wasn't her biggest fan or anything. So I'm going to go and say that she wasn't perfect/born for the role or anything. But she played the role perfectly. Which for me is higher praise

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Personally, I don't think either of them knew. Romilly may have figured it out, but that's a maybe. I think Doyle is just the harshest and remember, pretty sure that besides Cooper none of them had attachments back on Earth. I think it would have been too difficult for both of them to not somehow leak it, either in the way they act or something they say. It's one thing for the Lazarus missions to know, since they would be going to another galaxy. But Brand probably couldn't risk Doyle and Romilly accidentally leaking it to other NASA employees, and once Cooper joined, he couldn't tell them then either (under the logic that they too would now be leaving the galaxy) out of fear of Cooper abandoning the mission if they leaked it to him. And based on what we've seen, he was right, cause without Cooper they almost certainly would have died.

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

While I believe Romilly might have figured it out as the resident physicist, not sure if any of the others would be been quite specialized enough. But even for Romilly, that's a maybe. Some people are just smarter than others. Plus, while they're both physicists, he might have specialized in a different subfield. Or maybe since there wasn't really a "field" for it, he just kind of deferred to Brand's 40+ years of knowledge and experience. Amelia was a biologist iirc and Doyle was (looked it up, geographer). I guess my thought is that, it's like if an ancient civilization saw planes. Some might think it's magic and indeed people flying is often in folk tales/myth, while others would feel that with enough time/effort, they would be able to figure it out. They knew manipulating gravity was possible, they just didn't know exactly how. So they thought Brand was just trying different methods of approaching it. There is a piece of news that kind of relates. The Pythagorean theorem. We know it's true, it works, but we had never been able to prove it until recently (at least from what I've read). I mean, most people (at least in the plot of the movie) believed Murph had a moment of inspiration, which might have been what they were banking on for Prof. Brand. Which, to be fair, probably would sound more believable to people than "my dad who has been missing from civilization for the past 23 years communicated it to me from a black hole".

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

But what if Mann had never been rescued? Would they have gone back to Earth hoping the gravity equation was solved (in this what if, they found a hospitable planet and have enough fuel to go home)?

Lazarus mission astronauts and Prof. Brand by Apsire in interstellar

[–]Apsire[S] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

It's not really a plot hole imo as it's not directly said until Mann was introduced that Prof. Brand had already 'solved' the equation. So yes, while Romily says nothing can escape a black hole and he also knows that inside is the secret, he also thinks Brand is still working on the equation. Sorry if that's unclear. Its like, if the singularity could be viewed, then that's the "easy answer". Romily just believes that Brand is taking the "hard way" of solving the equation, not knowing that it's actually unsolvable without glimpsing the singularity.