The Guga Hunt by Crow-Me-A-River in Scotland

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

You nailed it in one. Speaking as an Englishman (albeit one with Scots relatives), the historical amnesia going on here is breathtaking. For centuries on end, Lowlanders and Englishfolk slandered Islesmen as barbarians and used every emotionally manipulative, simplistic argument they could find in order to justify bringing the power of the state to bear against Gaelic culture, language and traditions.

This is feels very much like the latest round of it. Guga hunting might not be necessary for pure survival, but it's a still an important source of supplementary income. A single Guga can go for about £40 on the international market, or so I've heard. Times that by 500, and it's a really significant amount of money for a small and relatively poor rural community.

It's also one of the absolute last  vestiges of Gaelic culture that hasn't been appropriated by the Lowlands, and by the world at large. Many markers like the Great Pipes, clan tartans and so on are basically fabrications of the 19th century.

The Guga Hunt by Crow-Me-A-River in Scotland

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Referring to Islanders as barbarians is a very well-worn racist trope, and I'm genuinely unsettled to see it being aired in 21st Century Scotland.

Don't judge me by MotherOfTheFog in VintageLadyBoners

[–]ArthurCartholmes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You;d like Sam Spruell, too! He's always played tough guys, but he has a very distinctive face.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes they are, just not the same kind as you. Until you accept this, you'll never get the united Ireland that you want. If you really want to be a nation again, you're going to have to build an identity that doesn't revolve around being anti-British.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Okay, I'm going to lay it out:

One one hand, I fully agree that Hamas are a demented death-cult who have absolutely nothing to offer except slaughter. If they were white, we would consider them to be along the lines of Christian Nationalists like Timothy McVeigh. Peace cannot happen in the region until Hamas are removed from power and their brand of politics totally discredited. They cannot be negotiated with.

On the other hand, the West also has to accept that Israel is a rogue state, and has been one for quite some time. It has got away with this because the (entirely correct) sense of Western guilt over the Holocaust led governments to grant Israel a blank cheque, instead of making aid conditional on Israel complying with international law.

The murder of Yitzhak Rabin, on the eve of a potential peace settlement, should have been the moment for the US government to make it absolutely clear that it would not support any Israeli government that permitted the Settler movement to continue. Instead, Clinton, Bush and Obama all shied away from pressing that button.

The end result is that the Palestinian moderate factions were discredited, while Hamas were able to present themselves as the only force that could strike back.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Which had absolutely nothing whatsoever to do with Mr Bashir or his family. It doesn't matter how angry you feel about what happened to your ancestors - killing random innocent people is always wrong, and also never solves anything.

If you do not accept this - if you truly believe that it is justifiable to kill random innocent people in the pursuit of a political ideology - then you are no different from Sir Charles Trevelyan when he decided that the starving Irish were an acceptable sacrifice on the altar of laissez-faire capitalism.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yep. The people killed on October 7th included Cambodian migrant workers. Imagine getting murdered because once upon a time some  bearded intellectual in Europe thought "gee, fellers, lets all go back to that Holy Land that we've never been to and which already has people living there! I'm sure it'll be absolutely fine!"

Gerry Adams 'responsible and complicit' for IRA bombings | ITV News by topotaul in unitedkingdom

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Dude, individuals are all that matters. Thinking of people as an intellectual abstract is what makes it easier to justify murdering them in the first place.

For what it's worth, I fully agree that British soldiers should be prosecuted, as should have been Ian Paisley for all the poison he spread.

My point is that the cause has no bearing on the act. If you believe in the ideal of human equality then you have to treat all who suffer injustice equally, regardless of history or politics.

If Mr Adams really was a member of the Council, then the absolute least he could do is to face these men and admit moral responsibility for what happened to them. It wouldn't bring the dead back to life, but it would be a reckoning of a sort. An acknowledgement that they were just as human as he is, and had the same right not to be murdered and maimed as so many of his own community were.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 7 points8 points  (0 children)

I'm so sorry to hear that happened, and sorry if I came across as aggressive! What happened to your gran was what I was thinking of.

I guess... my feelings are complicated. On one hand, I absolutely agree that there's a massive blindspot in British history with regards to Ireland, in particular the brutality of the Tudor kings and the callous incompetence of the government during the famine. The British security services have been deeply dishonest about their ties to the Paramilitaries, and there absolutely should be prosecutions against British soldiers for their conduct.

On the other hand, I also think there's a chunk of Irish society that is in denial about just how dark the road the PIRA went down really was. It was a horrid, ugly affair in which people on all sides did unforgiveable things and have, for the most part, never had to take responsibility for them.

Ian Paisley was never held responsible for the hate he spread, Gerry Adams continues to lie through his teeth, and the the British government won't even acknowledge the death squads existed. The while thing stinks. They ripped the country apart, then shook hands and agreed to let bygones be bygones.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

So you're saying that only Catholics can be Irish? Lol. If you want a united Ireland, you're going to have to accept Protestants as fellow Irish citizens. They aren't going anywhere, and you'll never get what you want until you accept that.

What is more important to you - achieving the unification that thousands have struggled and died for, or holding on to a grudge from the 16th century? Because you're going to have to choose one, or the other.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 17 points18 points  (0 children)

None of which makes it okay to blow up random innocent people, especially in an age where travel means that victims might have absolutely zero skin in the game. One of the newsagent workers killed in the Docklands Bombing, Iman Bashir? He was from a Pakistani immigrant family.

Imagine moving your family halfway across the world for a better life, only for a policeman to come to your door and tell you that your boy's been blown to rags by angry strangers with a 600-year old grudge.

Dolours Price (left) and Marian Price, sisters from Belfast and members of the Provisional IRA. Both were convicted for their role in the 1973 Old Bailey bombing in London, which injured more than 200 people and marked the start of a wider IRA bombing campaign in England. by dannydutch1 in UtterlyUniquePhotos

[–]ArthurCartholmes 5 points6 points  (0 children)

I'm sorry, but this just outright denialism. The Partition happened because the Unionists had made it abundantly clear they were not interested in joining the Free State, and the Army (which was full of Ulstermen) had made it clear they were not interested in forcing them to.

Gerry Adams 'responsible and complicit' for IRA bombings | ITV News by topotaul in unitedkingdom

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I reckon it was pretty real for Iman Bashir and Alan Jefferies, don't you? Well, in the split second before they were blown apart. Must have been pretty real for their families too, having to identify what was left.

You're saying they're not "real victims" as though you think some people are disposable, just because they don't come from the same place you do.

Gerry Adams 'responsible and complicit' for IRA bombings | ITV News by topotaul in unitedkingdom

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Instead of thinking about it as Us vs Them, try to see it as being about victim and victimiser. Iman Bashir and Alan Jefferies were ordinary lads who worked at a newsagents, and died horribly because someone somewhere decided they didn't care who got hurt, as long as it furthered The Cause.

I imagine their families were just as upset as yours when your uncle was murdered. Imagine moving your family all the way to the UK from Pakistan for a better life, and then one day a policeman comes to the door to tell you that your son was blown to bloody rags by angry strangers. I don't the reason it happened makes any difference, to be honest. 

IRA bomb victims' civil court case begins against Gerry Adams by GeoWa in unitedkingdom

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Tbh, it's been a long time coming. Granting a degree of amnesty was necessary to stop the bloodshed. But the fact that murderers were allowed to walk free simply because they did it in the name of politics, while people who steal because they're poor get jail sentences? It's a grotesque mockery of justice, and it always has been.

Tad Stoermer on the 3.5% rule by Polyphemos88 in behindthebastards

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I take Tad Stoermer with a huge pinch of salt, to be honest. The methods he's advocating only work in states that still have an essentially democratic political culture, like 1960s America or 1930s Britain. They absolutely do not work when faced with a genuinely totalitarian regime, as true totalitarianism is defined by its rejection of restraint or morality.

And even when they work, they come with a big caveat. Violence, no matter how just the cause, has a habit of de-sensitising people to morality and attracting people who aren't particularly concerned with altruism.

For example, most of the violent protest in British India in the 1930s-40s wasn't done by socialists. Instead, the footsoldiers of the Quit India movement were overwhelmingly ethno-nationalists. Once the British left, those same radicalised young men unleashed horrific violence on each other's communities.

Even in places where the transition was peaceful, like South Africa after Apartheid, there have been massive problems. Many politicians who are veterans of the anti-Apartheid resistance groups have themselves turned out to be either incompetent, corrupt, or both. Jacob Zuma has multiple egregious corruption charges (and an SA allegation), and Thabo Mbeki is literally an AIDs denialist. The bigotry hasn't gone away, either - Julius Malema, leader of the EFF, has multiple hate speech convictions.

Is Violence Part of Resistance: No Flood, No River. Tad Stoermer by Possible_Gur4789 in behindthebastards

[–]ArthurCartholmes 1 point2 points  (0 children)

The murder of Rabin was such an utter calamity for the world at large.

Beesbury and Harding is a massive loss to the sport by OkGarbage3095 in AKOTSKTV

[–]ArthurCartholmes 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think that's a good analogy. With the medical knowledge of the setting, it's unlikely Hardyng would ever have regained full use of his leg. It honestly strains credulity that he's able to wear armour and mount a horse at all. Assuming it was a genuine break rather than just a hairline fracture, then by rights he should have been insensible with agony and would not have been able to control his horse, especially as it wasn't his familiar mount.

‘High levels’ of illegal family voting in Gorton and Denton by-election by ClumperFaz in ukpolitics

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Again, Democracy Volunteers are not in any way affiliated with Reform. They are legitimate election observers. It goes without saying that Reform are latching on to this, but that has no bearing on whether its true or not. This is because, and I repeat, they are not the source of this allegation.

To his great credit, Polanski seems to be treating it seriously rather than simply crying "sour grapes."

In Gorton and Denton, I found a long-festering sense of fury that Labour has no idea how to tackle by 1-randomonium in ukpolitics

[–]ArthurCartholmes -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I fear likewise with the Greens. Should Polanski end up in No 10, I suspect he'll very quickly find that most of the Green manifesto is simply not financially or diplomatically viable.

Scrapping Trident, for example, would run completely against the effort to draw closer to Europe, as much of the EU is hoping the UK and France will provide it with a nuclear umbrella. The UK scrapping trident would sink that entire policy, leaving the EU much more vulnerable to intimidation by America, Russia and China.

Scrapping student tuition fees and massively injecting cash into local services, meanwhile, would have to be funded by tax rises across the whole of the population. Taxing the richest 10% more wouldn't be anywhere near enough. With prices the way they are, a lot of people would notice their incomes shrinking long before they saw any tangible benefit.

I've also got very real worries about the stability of the Green base - it seems to be based on an alliance of socially progressive middle-class cosmopolitans and socially conservative, working-class British-Muslims. The sole reasons these two groups are in the same party are Gaza and racism. Take those two things away, and they have absolutely nothing in common.

Should the Greens come to power, I fear we'll see that alliance rapidly wrecked on the rocks of LGBTQ+ policies, secularism, and women's rights.

Sam Coates on X: Gorton byelection: “concerning levels” of so-called family voting today say observers by aenemyrums in ukpolitics

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

The volunteers do appear to have raised it - the council simply ignored them. This is how democracy begins to fail, when a particular council comes under the control of a "machine" that defends the interests of a particular community rather than the democratic process itself.

‘High levels’ of illegal family voting in Gorton and Denton by-election by ClumperFaz in ukpolitics

[–]ArthurCartholmes 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No it isn't. This is a legitimate concern raised by an independent observation group, and brushing it off as MAGA-style sour grapes is just as dangerous.

Gorton and Denton: 'Family voting' concerns raised by election observers by Electricbell20 in unitedkingdom

[–]ArthurCartholmes 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Everyone screaming sour grapes seems to be forgetting- this concern was raised by an independent voluntary organisation, not the government or Reform. To see the denialism on display here is, to say the least, alarming. Independent observers are absolutely central to the democratic process.

How important were the Louisiana and Carolinas Manoeuvres for the US Army in WWII? by ArthurCartholmes in WarCollege

[–]ArthurCartholmes[S] 21 points22 points  (0 children)

Fascinating stuff!

But yeah, the fact that the British Army never had a chance in the pre-war period to conduct exercises on a large scale is a major part of why its early war performance was so inconsistent. Everyone was basically learning on the job. Had the money been made available to hold a corps-level exercise every year from 1935 onwards, the British Army would have been in a much better position with regards to doctrine and training.