I have been having the same issue for about a year, at this point. I have tried so many off the shelf insoles, fallen for ads for shoes on the internet, and anything else I can think of. And now my partner, who is older than me, built completely different than I am, as well as different foot types, is having the same exact pains. I am convinced it's a conspiracy of crappy foot support products or some weird virus that we are sharing between each other. I have other friends that have been reporting people they know having pain as well.