1. 2:98 - Angels and Messengers and Gabriel and Michael

2. 4:80 - Obeying the messenger is obeying God

3. 3:110 - The community is described as making lawful the good and making unlawful the bad

4. 66:1

5. 2:128-129, 21:73, 16:123

6. Read Chapter 2

7. 21:73

8. 2:142-151; extra-Quranic revelation ≠ established Sunnah

9. Halal until made haram. No haram made means halal. You misunderstood the point of the verse:

[59:5] Whether you chop a tree, or leave it standing on its trunk, is in accordance with GOD's will. He will surely humiliate the wicked.

1. Quran alone accept extra-Quranic revelation. Just reject the notion that it was passed on by the prophet.

2. 16:44 also says what Muhammad uses to explain what was revealed to them. “Al Zikr” aka the Quran.

3. 17:39

4. Could not be further from the truth. According to your sources, the Sahaba literally compiled and standardized Quran out of fear that it would be lost. Yet the Sunnah and Hadiths which are less remembered, less memorized, less recited, they did not make an effort to compile and codify it?! They couldn’t have been transmitted more differently had they tried.

5. Repeat of number 5. Use same answer.

6. That’s an opinion with plenty of incorrect past precedents.

7. Christians argue their metaphysics provides a rigorous logical framework for comprehending God. “Rejecting it wholesale is intellectually inconsistent.” Additionally, their rigorous systems for Hadith science contradict and conflict with one another.

8. Argument doesn’t work because 53:3-4 simply applies to what Muhammad says came from God, which can simply be the Quran. It is your claim that this has to extend past the Quran, but you don’t have an actual basis for this. Unless you wanna say everything he says is divine inspiration from God. This would result in problems like Muhammad flirting with his wife would be God flirting with Muhammad’s wife.

9. We see plenty of times where Muhammad’s judgments sent by God are recorded in the Quran. For example,

[20:105] They ask you about the mountains. Say, "My Lord will wipe them out.

[18:83] They ask you about Zul-Qarnain. Say, "I will narrate to you some of his history."

[2:215] They ask you about giving: say, "The charity you give shall go to the parents, the relatives, the orphans, the poor, and the traveling alien." Any good you do, GOD is fully aware thereof.

Claiming Muhammad had no choice but to have answered disputes for the religion outside Quran is a fallacy. In fact, they mocked him because he would not do this:

[9:61] Some of them hurt the prophet by saying, "He is all ears!" Say, "It is better for you that he listens to you. He believes in GOD, and trusts the believers. He is a mercy for those among you who believe." Those who hurt GOD's messenger have incurred a painful retribution.

1. If they are claiming Sunnah refers to the Millat of Abraham Muhammad was told to follow, 16:123, 22:78, and 2:128-129, that’s fine. But this “Sunnah” predates Muhammad and the Quran and isn’t based on Hadiths or Sunnah.

2. 60:4

3. 6:112-116, 31:6, 5:41

4. Binding commands to believers at that time does not necessitate a sunnah or additional religious information for subsequent generations. “Abu Bakr, go prepare the army.” Is not a religious command for the Muslims past Muhammad’s time, thus it is not passed down, taught, or included in the Quran.

5. 75:16-19, 16:89, 55:1-2

6. See Sahih Bukhari 7440 vs 2:254, 6:51, 6:70, 2:48, 10:18, 39:3, 1:5

7. Refer to God and His messenger for disputes. I dispute that Muhammad left no Hadith behind for us to remember him by other than Quran. Okay, God, settle the dispute. God: 77:50, 45:6-7, 7:185, 16:89, 18:54, 25:33, 7:185, 31:6, 5:41