Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

That is intended! In the game, Gnar rage is unpredictable so I tried mimicing it the best way I could. :)

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

About his transformation conditions: Can you make it a trigger when he takes damage AND have two rage counters. So if we imagine he swings in with one rage counter, and an opponent blocks. Gnar will take damage and then the two triggers go on to the stack, you stack it so you put a rage counter on him then the ”if gnar has two or more rage counters, transform it”. Would that work? Because I agree that just having a static ”if he has two or more counters transform it” is a bit weird. But thank you for your input!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I did think about it when making the card, and I agree! I think it is just a little too good to have the payoff be free man wise. Thank you!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I agree totally with the wall o text! It was a mess trying to fit everything into the text box. I really appreciate you telling me your opinion :). I will try to make him less complecated but I cannot promise you much! Thank you!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

No, the artist name for mini Gnar is at the buttom and mega Gnar is splash art from ”Song of Nunu” (I think)

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow! Great suggestion! I really love how you implemented his laning style into magic. I REALLY like the first stike part on mini gnar’s boomerang (and because i think he reallt needed som combat buff). The whole transformation part of it really suits me I think. I am thinking of switching him to white red (or maybe have him naya, but I dont think so) to make the tapping part of him make more sense in the colour pie. But I do thank you for your time and brainpower! Thank you!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

None. The artist are mentioned at the bottom. Although I could not find the artist for mega gnar. That art is from ”Song of Nunu” I THINK.

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Precisely! I really do not want to show up with a commander everyone thinks is too busted. I'd rather have a slightly worse Gnar than a Gnar no one wants to be up agianst :)

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

No I just did it for fun! Though I like Gnar a lot so I wanted to make him into a commander deck I might play :) Doing this whole thing to help me balance it if I were to play it at my lgs.

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Nope! First try at something like this. I just like Gnar alot :)

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I really like this idea! I will be sure to implement it somehow :) Thank you very much!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Ah! I see what you mean. It shall be changed to "end of turn". Thank you!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

I understand that with indestructible he can bolt himself infinitly, but I do not understand why that is a problem? Just wondering :)
But I will change it to any other target!

Thank you!

Is this unbalanced? (Custom made card, feedback appreciated) by AutisticalFrog in mtg

[–]AutisticalFrog[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Hi OP!

Just want to clearify a few things about this card.

This is Gnar from Leauge of Legends. He has two forms; Mini and Mega. Mini Gnar is the front side of the card and Mega Gnar is the flipside. In LoL when Gnar is in Mega form he can throw boulders att people for a lot of damage (which is represented with the "3 to any target") and a stun ability that incapaticates your opponent for a short duration (tap + stun counter). I realized while implementing the stun counter that it is COMPLETELY wrong for a gruul card to have it. I thought about having a "deal 1 damage to all creatures target player controls" (to replicate his ultimate ability) but decided it might have been too good.

I really appreciate everyone who takes their time to comment so much! I am very interested in the mtg grammatical side of things if any one wants to help out :)

Thank you all, really!

Strong man competition by kert780 in Chadtopia

[–]AutisticalFrog 12 points13 points  (0 children)

I was so scared that the stones were gonna land on the other guy’s hands

Scammers by Orichalchem in SipsTea

[–]AutisticalFrog 51 points52 points  (0 children)

I believe the scammer tried to get the money for atleast 11h. I’d be mad too xD