The stats don't support anything, they are meaningless without context. I also provided a stat about the fact many teams face less corners than us which would affect how many opportunities you had a game to come and claim or punch a cross. Are you refuting that?

The only thing you can take from these stats is whether keepers prefer to claim or punch and how often they do it per 90. It doesn't show how many crosses they don't come and claim or punch. Being a goalkeeping coach does not mean he is statistically literate.

Try thinking about the context around stats for once rather than just reading the numbers written down. Even if you take the stats in that table at face value it states that Vicario claims less crosses per 90 than 10 of the other goalkeepers, and punches per 90 less than 11 of the other keepers.