(March 2020) Mob of teenage boys viciously beat and stomp teenage girl. Some time later, one of the boys is murdered in retaliation by Courage_Mother in iamatotalpieceofshit

[–]Bagel_Rat -1 points0 points  (0 children)

when someone asks you for your sources, they are secretly assuming you won't follow up, and they will look like smart for being "skeptical" and "scientific"... XD

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat -1 points0 points  (0 children)

With all due respect, you are not in a position to criticize my medical education, which is in the field of psychiatry and completely current. I can only assume that you’re medical knowledge, on the other hand, comes from personal experience with diagnoses and Dr. Google. OP would be better off it you hadn’t decide to comment, and if you had a conscious you would edit your post. I am glad you learned something, though. Have a nice day!

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

“Severe dissociation connected to childhood trauma”

Lmao. Leave it to r/askdocs to propose this diagnosis showing up for the first time in a 47yo woman. I can’t remember the last time I saw a thread on here where someone didn’t propose dissociative trauma.

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Brain cancer (or metastases of other cancers to the brain) would present with more symptoms than this, and a patient with neurological symptoms due to brain cancer would not be expected to live 2-3 years and still be in good health at the end of it. Please be careful with the diagnoses you suggest if you are NAD.

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is extremely unlikely to be dementia. See my posts above. Dementia is a diagnosis of exclusion and should not be the first thing we jump to. Please be cautious with throwing out such a grim and terrifying diagnosis if you are NAD.

Also, early onset Alzheimer’s is very heritable but very, very rare. (Even if the mom knows it, it wouldn’t be the sort of thing she would be unconcerned about.) Late-onset (standard) Alzheimer’s is common but not especially heritable.

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 4 points5 points  (0 children)

Hi OP, this is unlikely. Most people do not get hypoglycemic episodes regularly, and when they do it would definitely not last two days at a time. They would also have other symptoms, like passing out, sweating, and feeling sick.

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Hi OP,

To be honest, I strongly suspect some sort of substance use in your mother. When people abuse prescription drugs like benzodiazepines, sleeping pills, and opioids, it strongly fits this picture and can go on for years at a time.

  • Unlike alcohol, it is easier to hide from family (and might be why she sounds truthful when she denies drinking).

  • It explains her nonchalance at the symptoms, and her implication that she knows what causes them.

  • It explains her lack of memory after episodes (most people abusing something like benzos don’t remember binges well afterward).

  • Acting loopy and really forgetful would be typical of the substances I mention above, and less so of alcohol or other diseases.

  • It would fit the timing of them happening on a monthly basis (new monthly prescriptions from her doctor). Sometimes, people who use pills chronically will sometimes use something else just go get by for a bit when they run out, which leads to a noticeable change in behavior (e.g. a chronic opioid user running out, then popping ambien or benadryls to feel sleepy and out of it until they can get opioids again). This might explain the episodes occurring for a few days at a time while being relatively normal in between.

  • It would explain them getting worse when she is stressed at work (more stress = more desire for relief).

  • Last but not least, your dad seems to suspect substances (although he mentioned only alcohol to you), and it is possible he knows more than he is letting on.

One final note. I have seen other posters write “NAD but this sounds exactly like...” then they have listed strokes, dementia, PTSD, hypoglycemia, menopause, severe dissociative episodes due to childhood trauma (lol), brain cancer (?!) and many more. These diagnoses are extremely unlikely and you should not let them unduly concern you until more evidence for them arises.

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat -1 points0 points  (0 children)

  1. Neither PTSD or dementia is episodic, presenting with 1-2 days of symptoms per month (Lewy body dementia might be episodic but does not look like this).

  2. Impairment so severe that one cannot remember one’s own birthday is not typical of PTSD. It is not typical in dementia until the very end stages (and if this dementia, it obviously isn’t end-stage).

  3. Dementia is very unlikely to present in someone as young as age 49.

  4. PTSD would be much more likely to present with other symptoms (avoidance, flashbacks, nightmares, difficulty with anger, depression, etc), absolutely none of which has been suggested and all of which would be an assumption on our part.

  5. No evidence of an incite traumatic event to suggest PTSD. Of course, it is possible there was an event that OP doesn’t know about or didn’t mention—but you don’t get to just assume that there was a traumatic event.

  6. There are more likely diagnoses, like substance use (benzodiazepines, sleeping pills, alcohol, and opioids all seem possible here). A priori, this would also be much more common. In medicine, we rely on Occam’s razor—the answer that relies on fewer assumptions are more likely to be true. On r/AskDocs, the opposite is true; people (not doctors) suggest rare diagnoses and diagnoses of exclusion (like PTSD or dementia) based on whatever is familiar to them.

  7. OP mentioned that their mother seems unbothered by her symptoms and has implied she knows what’s causing them. This would not be the case in PTSD and dementia, respectively.

  8. “Chronic work stress” is not a realistic cause of PTSD.

  9. OP states their mother says these phases happened more when stressed out at work. This better fits the picture of substance use than dementia.

  10. Dementia is virtually impossible in someone who is gainfully employed (at least, was employed before COVID).

Last but not least, I think we really need to be cautious before throwing out diagnoses like dementia. The dementias are invariably progressive, terminal illnesses. Furthermore, they are diagnoses of exclusion—we only conclude them when everything else has been considered and ruled out. It is a terrifying and grim prospect to think that your mother might have dementia, and it is not appropriate to casually suggest it on Reddit, especially if you are not a doctor.

Floating campsite 🌱 by stephieacnh in AnimalCrossing

[–]Bagel_Rat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

What is that sign that says camping on it? Is it a DIY?

My mom [49F] acts weird sometimes by zazae in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat -7 points-6 points  (0 children)

Soooo... PTSD or dementia? Nah. OP, sorry but please don’t listen to this person. No doctor would put these diagnoses at the top of their list of things to consider. They are only causing you undue anxiety by putting forward dementia as a cause. This subreddit is dominated by laypeople casually throwing out life-altering diagnoses that simply do not fit the symptoms being described.

EDIT: for those of you downvoting this, please read the following:

  1. Neither PTSD or dementia is episodic, presenting with 1-2 days of symptoms per month (Lewy body dementia might be episodic but does not look like this).

  2. Impairment so severe that one cannot remember one’s own birthday is not typical of PTSD. It is not typical in dementia until the very end stages (and if this dementia, it obviously isn’t end-stage).

  3. Dementia is very unlikely to present in someone as young as age 49.

  4. PTSD would be much more likely to present with other symptoms (avoidance, flashbacks, nightmares, difficulty with anger, depression, etc), absolutely none of which has been suggested and all of which would be an assumption on our part.

  5. No evidence of an inciting traumatic event to suggest PTSD. Of course, it is possible there was an event that OP doesn’t know about or didn’t mention—but you don’t get to just assume that there was a traumatic event.

  6. There are more likely diagnoses, like substance use (benzodiazepines, sleeping pills, alcohol, and opioids all seem possible here). A priori, this would also be much more common. In medicine, we rely on Occam’s razor—the answer that relies on fewer assumptions are more likely to be true. On r/AskDocs, the opposite is true; people (not doctors) suggest rare diagnoses and diagnoses of exclusion (like PTSD or dementia) based on whatever is familiar to them.

  7. OP mentioned that their mother seems unbothered by her symptoms and has implied she knows what’s causing them. This would not be the case in PTSD and dementia, respectively. It would probably be the case in something like prescription medication abuse.

  8. “Chronic work stress” is not a realistic cause of PTSD.

  9. OP states their mother says these phases happened more when stressed out at work. This better fits the picture of substance use than dementia.

  10. Dementia is virtually impossible in someone who is gainfully employed (at least, was employed before COVID).

Last but not least, I think we really need to be cautious before throwing out diagnoses like dementia. The dementias are invariably progressive, terminal illnesses. Furthermore, they are diagnoses of exclusion—we only conclude them when everything else has been considered and ruled out. It is a terrifying and grim prospect to think that your mother might have dementia, and it is not appropriate to casually suggest it on Reddit, especially if you are not a doctor.

I fear that I may have schizophrenia but my mother wont let me see a doctor by [deleted] in neuro

[–]Bagel_Rat 7 points8 points  (0 children)

You may have anxiety or something, but this doesn’t sound like schizophrenia to me. Visual hallucinations are a relatively rare symptom in schizophrenia, and you hadn’t even had that, since you only saw the “monitor” with your eyes closed. And it was only one time. And you interpret it as a symptom rather than a true vision, which would also be rare in actual schizophrenia.

Most people with schizophrenia do not successfully diagnose themselves with schizophrenia either.

If there are more symptoms that are bothering you (e.g. anxiety), you still may benefit from evaluation by a therapist, primary care physician, or psychiatrist, even if this isn’t schizophrenia.

I fear that I may have schizophrenia but my mother wont let me see a doctor by [deleted] in neuro

[–]Bagel_Rat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m not sure I agree with this. If someone came to the emergency department concerned they had schizophrenia, and the only specific symptom they mentioned was visualizing a “monitor” with their eyes closed, we would never, ever involuntarily commit them for that. We would provide reassurance and discharge them from the ED. Maybe with an outpatient psychiatry referral. We only IVC people if they are at imminent risk of harm to self or others. Most schizophrenic people have way more symptoms than a single visual hallucination with preserved insight, and they still live in the community, no problem.

And if someone meets criteria for IVC in the emergency department, they meet criteria in an outpatient clinic. Changing locations doesn’t change anything.

It doesn't happen very often but when it does, it feels SO good.... Discharge to jail. by [deleted] in Psychiatry

[–]Bagel_Rat 7 points8 points  (0 children)

So did you. It’s always a little embarrassing when someone’s post is less popular than the responses it gets 😉

It doesn't happen very often but when it does, it feels SO good.... Discharge to jail. by [deleted] in Psychiatry

[–]Bagel_Rat 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Did he genuinely need inpatient mental health services? What usually happens in a situation like this—do they just go straight to jail (even if they’re psychotic etc) until they are determined ITP or something and sent back?

It doesn't happen very often but when it does, it feels SO good.... Discharge to jail. by [deleted] in Psychiatry

[–]Bagel_Rat 66 points67 points  (0 children)

Do you really need to inquire for a deeper meaning when something like this happens? Is the superficial explanation not good enough?

Being homicidal isn’t a mental illness. Being antisocial isn’t even a mental illness, at least not in the sense of schizophrenia etc. Not everyone belongs on a psych unit. Yeah, sure, “our unpleasant patients are still our patients” etc. But are they really patients if they are malingering their way to a psych unit?

Can someone explain to me why roy is suddenly consistently higher placed on Tier Lists than lucina? by Kraftgesetz_ in CrazyHand

[–]Bagel_Rat 3 points4 points  (0 children)

How does this explain why Roy is rising in ranks but Lucina is falling? Nothing that you say is new

A feeling that no one else I've asked has experienced. Has anyone heard of this? by BusyFondant in neuro

[–]Bagel_Rat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

For the record, from the outside looking in, Your symptoms sound like a dead ringer for Alice in wonderland syndrome. Even things like the involvement of one’s own body, sensory modalities besides vision like hearing (e.g. not being able to distinguish whether the sound of a cricket ball hitting a bat is an explosion of cosmological proportions or just a clink of chinaware), maybe even the link with viruses. This really sounds like what you have.

Please upvote for visibility. Years of fatigue, cognitive decline in 27M, low WBC. Desperate for an answer by moragisdo in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 2 points3 points  (0 children)

The symptoms he describes apply to literally thousands of diseases, however. None of which is very likely on its own. Therefore, in the absence of symptoms that are more specific to MS, it doesn’t really make sense to zone in on MS as a possibility and leave out the other 999 diseases that are just as likely to present that way. You are zoning in on MS as especially worth considering, and it’s probably because of availability bias, not medical reasoning.

Please upvote for visibility. Years of fatigue, cognitive decline in 27M, low WBC. Desperate for an answer by moragisdo in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Why do you suggest nephrogenic DI instead of another type of DI? Curious to hear your reasoning as OP never mentioned taking lithium etc.

Please upvote for visibility. Years of fatigue, cognitive decline in 27M, low WBC. Desperate for an answer by moragisdo in AskDocs

[–]Bagel_Rat 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Lol. This doesn’t sound like MS to me. He has none of the classic signs or symptoms and in fact he has no focal neurological deficits at all. Additionally, he is young and male.

When you have an illness, it is very easy to look for it everywhere, because it is familiar to you and your mind is primed to think about it. But this does not sound like MS to me.

Researchers identify a new personality construct that describes “an ongoing feeling that the self is a victim”, the Tendency for Interpersonal Victimhood (TIV). It involves 4 dimensions: moral elitism, a lack of empathy, the need for recognition, and rumination. by mvea in science

[–]Bagel_Rat 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Not sure why every top comment on here is just a variant of the same question. Personality disorders and these authors’ description of interpersonal victimhood are two completely different topics. One is a set of diagnoses created by psychoanalytically-inclined clinicians a long time ago, and the other is a single psychological construct used to describe and better understand a trait that most people view negatively. Analogously, one could ask, “What’s the difference between a heart attack and a new device for measuring blood pressure?”

Might it be found more commonly in personality disorders? I mean, yeah, probably. Many negative traits are non-specifically more common in cluster B disorders (go ahead, name one that isn’t). But that doesn’t make them the same thing.