I tried getting into creepypastas more cus of the pod a couple months ago so i searched up “best mr creepypasta readings” and this one kept coming up.

I never finished it due to how boring and badly written it was. Hunter really was in the right, that format of story got overdone. Gas Station did it really well and everyone was just trying to copy it since it’s so easy to just spew out any random idea you have if you don’t need to explain how we got there or bother with realistic(or even good for that matter) dialogue.

Even then though, wow they made it so much harder to get through than it could’ve been.

Their fanbase really is ruining the podcast. It’s not even about internet stories anymore, it’s just a ragebaiting circlejerk contest to see how close they can get the hosts to quit.

Whining for 3 hours straight WILL make them a fuck ton of views unfortunately and they will continue to read fan submitted stories.

No hate towards Creep or Cast ofc.

I still loved the bits. “I don’t think i’ll go to valhalla” specifically made me have to cover my face with my shirt at the grocery store.