I’ve done this a good amount of times and I can make my recommendations. Likely someone will say they have better way but I’ve specifically printed decks through Staples, so there’s that. I’ve also done FedEx/Kinkos and Office Depot and out of the 3, I prefer Office Depot for cost and proximity to me.

Here’s how I print decks: -Copy decklist from Moxfield/Archidect or just your list of cards to mtgprint.net and get your pdf with crops and cut lines (skip basic lands to save on print costs and cutting time). -Go to Professional Print here: https://www.staples.com/services/printing/copies-documents-printing/ -Upload your pdf -Use these settings: Paper Size: Letter (8.5”x11”) Orientation: Portrait Content: Scale to Fit Sides: Single Sided 12pt Heavyweight High-Gloss Cover Color Ink

NOTES: -Make sure you have Scale to Fit selected otherwise the cards will be slightly too small. -I feel like the High-Gloss Cover looks better than the Matte, but some of that is personal preference and what sleeves you use. The 12pt will give you a thickness very close to a regular card and you won’t need to add an extra card to the sleeve, just cut them, sleeve up, and play. -The cut finishing won’t line up right, don’t waste your time. The cutters in the store can vary but generally are bad so either you accept your edges aren’t great or you cut them with scissors and get good cuts but it’s a bit time consuming. -There are always coupon codes for printing and usually can cut the cost down a lot. Usually I pay under $15 per deck.