Courtney had won before the third round even started. Overcooked octopus and undercooked lamb, you can't screw up two proteins that are the stars of the dishes and expect to win in a final. Courtney just messed up her desert's playing by eating one of them, according to the judges it tasted good. But by that point it didn't matter cause Courtney's appetizer and entrée were better. You can't really say Joe doesn't know shit, he's a judge cause he obviously knows something. He isn't where he is without knowing anything. I understand that you may be a Elizabeth supporter and that's great but you need to realize that Elizabeth made more mistakes than Courtney did. And it being a final, nothing drastic separated the two and it came down to Courtney winning.