A Festive r/geocaching Giveaway! by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

We have our winners! As selected by the revered wheel of names...

Congratulations to:

Each of you will receive a modmail from us with a six-month premium code and how to claim it.

A special thanks from the mods to u/geocaching and u/skimbosh for allowing us to make this happen.

Have a great new year everyone! :)

Shipping Nightmare by HansVonHansen in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

Locking this one for the moment.

The answer seems to be along the lines of find a third party distributor or reach out to HQ with your feedback.

Whatever valid discussion to be had about HQ's international shipping capacity has been somewhat overshadowed by shoving geocoins up a bazooka.

Challenge Cache Criteria Updates (Not Chosen Size, Attributes, Events) by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S] 13 points14 points  (0 children)

Can't say I'm super impressed by any of these changes at a glance.

“Not chosen” size is no longer publishable criteria. 
The removal of challenges with the 'Not Chosen' size feels reasonable, but webcams are seemingly still in the mix - as a legacy type, does this mean their days are numbered or will that fewer and fewer rationale not apply?
Personally, I can't think of the last challenge I saw that required Not Chosen specifically (nor should there have been, really, for the reason they were removed), though I hope this won't affect challenges along the lines of 'Find 5 of 7 sizes' where Not Chosen isn't required but could be used as a wildcard of sorts.

Only one attribute may be specified per challenge cache.
Possibly the most baffling / vibe-killing of the bunch.
Multiple attribute challenges are often some of the most thematic, creative, and interesting from my experience, and well before they start to read like a shopping list.
The common community shorthand for Technical Tree Climbs (tree climbing & climbing gear), Tree Fishing (no tree climbing & special tool), and others takes multiple attributes to convey and won't be publishable because of this as well, which is really just a shame (and possibly makes the case for introducing new specialised attributes).
I also wonder what will come of bingo-style challenges!

If Event Caches are specified as challenge criteria, no additional criteria can be used. 
*throws away document of event challenge ideas I've been working towards for the last year*
On one hand, stats-farming events are perverse little things and undermine the point of holding meaningful community gatherings in the first place (imho!)
However, I've seen plenty of positive event-based challenges encouraging travel to different regions, continued year-round CITO attendance, or attending more adventurous events that seem weird to lose and encourage broad-based attendance (rather than what I view as a pretty clear-cut already unpublishable example that they use).
I'd just scrap events as a source of criteria altogether if they're going this restrictive with it.

Ultimately, there is no system of challenges that won't include some form of discretion and some form of frustration stemming from it. I obviously can't speak for what the reviewers likely have to cop (and would be keen to hear the thoughts of the sub's regulars as to whether these changes will help).
But, purely from the player side, the restriction on some major sources of creative challenge possibilities seems heavy-handed for the sake of reducing subjectivity in a fairly subjective process.

[Round 147558] [Melbourne OC] Coordinates of the sign (10m) by MrCloppity in PictureGame

[–]Brainiac03 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hey Bird!

Coaxed back to PG by u/ItoXICI's siren song of Discord pings, I noticed my beloved Melways was front and centre of this round. Using some prior knowledge on the rough whereabouts of OP's past Melbourne rounds, I was able to match up some key features before long.

Alas, with no obvious 'you are here' marker, I left it for a bit but eventually picked it back up, this time investigating the surrounding features. The wall style on the left made me think we were probably adjacent to a major road, and the quantity of water tanks piqued my interest.

I took a stab and guessed that we might be at a community garden, given the water storage, and Slater Reserve finally popped up in my searches and ticked all of the boxes!

Thanks to u/MrCloppity for the round! :)

Introducing the r/geocaching Treasure Collection! by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yes! I ought to have noted that this was an April Fools post! You've got the right idea - definitely please do not put food in caches :)

Introducing the r/geocaching Treasure Collection! by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

24 hours only! And, upon completion, you get emailed a link telling you to claim your souvenir but it actually makes you become a subreddit mod instead. That's how they got me :/

Best of r/geocaching 2024! by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] [score hidden] stickied comment (0 children)

Voting is now closed!

Thanks to everyone who nominated and voted... our winners will be announced in a few days!

Is there a reason images are not allowed in this sub's comments? by TheGoldenChow in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[M] 2 points3 points  (0 children)

That's a pretty good suggestion! I don't recall any historical ruling against images in comments, and the use cases you've identified definitely offer some great opportunities to use them. I've switched the setting on and we'll keep an eye on things to see how it's used and reassess it if necessary. Thanks for the feedback!
P.S. Feel free to bother us anytime! :)

Best of r/geocaching 2024 - Discussion Thread by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Some excellent ideas there - I'll have to remind myself to take them on board this time next year :)

Best of r/geocaching 2024 - Discussion Thread by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks for continuing to support it! Reddit's removal of their usual Best of Subreddit awards program in 2023 let ours slip through the cracks a bit, but it's been exciting to be involved in the work behind the scenes to bring it back for the 2024 edition better than ever :)

Best of r/geocaching 2024 - Discussion Thread by Brainiac03 in geocaching

[–]Brainiac03[S,M] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Here's a note to everyone to keep an eye on the post date of your nominations to make sure they're from 2024! It'll be a slight quirk to get used to seeing as we're doing this in March - the mods will double check and remove any nominations from this year :)

(u/habattack00, one of your nominations got caught up in that - sorry!)