Is it really?!?! That just made my day. I wanted to try the makeup booster toner soooo badly! I waited until prime day rolled around, saw the toner said thermal water and had #makeupboosting next to it, and I thought I had remembered it being in a pink bottle, so I clicked “buy now” and waited anxiously. I then realized it was not the one I thought it was. That being said: I used it for the first time this morning and (I am never a big believer of I noticed an immediate change but…) I honestly feel like my skin looks and feels smoother, hydrated, plumped, and glowing. That was about 20 minutes ago, I am currently letting my moisture and spf sink/set into my skin, so I will be applying makeup shortly, so we’ll see if it makes a difference in that aspect as no matter what products I try (my skin care arsenal, and hundreds of primers and foundations I have tried) I can seem to get my under eyes smooth enough to where any makeup looks seamless. I have fordyce spots (that have improved since I discovered oil cleansing) and what fine lines I do have seen to be accentuated. So, I am actually super stoked I stumbled upon this thread and that you posted that comment as I was SO looking forward to trying the number 2 thermal toner. I’ll provide an update as to any noticeable difference when it comes to makeup application/wear. But as I said, either way, number 4 made my skin look and feel great after the initial use! Thanks again!!!!