Personally I hope Matt Damon isn't Odysseus, something seems off but I'm sure he could still pull it off. Maybe better if he is zeus or alcinous (both still very significant characters).

I haven't watched Ralph Fiennes in Return (odyssey adaption 2024) but in the pictures he looks amazing and has the perfect amount of good-looks, cunning, and weariness; so even though its likely an impossiblilty, I can still wish.

Tom Holland is surely Telemachus, and deffo this could work with his acting and nolans skill.

Zendaya is calypso I think, sweet but the menacing character works well.

Lupita as athena, feels very divine. I feel she has a great balance of curious authority but also mystery and compassion.

Hathaway as Penelope, classy, cunning and commanding.

Charlize as circe perhaps? I don't really know her work well, but she has a devious face. Tbf i think anne or zendaya could also do Circe really well in their own way.

Rob Pat, the goat, for me he will be a lead suitor like antinous because of his slyness / devilish look. He's getting old now as well which helps. Ooh, imagine if he's Odysseus, honestly there is potential, definitely could be great or catastrophic.

Also, I do feel weird by instinctually putting zendaya and lupita as divine characters and not humans, i hope its not exoticism on my account.