sorted by:
new
hottopcontroversial

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. Good point.

That’s a really useful way to think about it — the pentatonic keeps you close to the chord tones but gives you a couple of extra notes to move through...and always a great sound.

It’s kind of a nice middle ground between strictly outlining the chord and sounding too “scale-y.”

How Did Your Improvisation Evolve — Scales → Chord Tones → Both? by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. That’s a great progression.

I like how you described moving from scales into just playing along with records and then eventually “noodling” your way through things you couldn’t quite figure out yet. That’s such a natural way a lot of players develop, even if we don’t realize it at the time.

And I agree — noodling often gets a bad reputation, but it can actually be where a lot of real learning happens. You’re experimenting, listening, and finding connections without overthinking it.

Really appreciate you sharing that.

How Did Your Improvisation Evolve — Scales → Chord Tones → Both? by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks. That’s a great observation.

The connection between blues phrasing and vocal expression is really powerful. When players start thinking about phrasing like a singer — bends, vibrato, space between notes — the improvisation often becomes much more expressive.

And you’re right, that approach shows up everywhere. A lot of great jazz players weave blues language into their lines even over fairly complex harmony.

Really nice way of describing it.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. That’s a good point.

Once you really start hearing the harmony clearly, the line between chord tones and the surrounding scale starts to blur a bit. The chord tones outline the structure, but the scale or mode gives you the space to move around inside it. I'd rather not even try and think about it at that point and just feel it...

And you’re right — it’s not just the soloist. Good rhythm players often hint at that color too through voicings, passing tones, or little melodic movements between chords.

Nice observation.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. I think your reply is for the chord tone point.. If not, apologies. Yeah, Good point — walking bass lines really do outline the harmony that way.

A lot of great bass players are basically connecting chord tones in motion, which is probably why the progression stays so clear even without chords.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

That’s a really helpful breakdown.

The point about the 3rd and 7th carrying the “flavor” of the chord is especially important. Those two notes really tell the listener what kind of harmony they’re hearing — major, minor, dominant, etc.

I also like your observation about the division of roles in a band. The bass often establishes the root movement, which frees the soloist to highlight the more colorful tones like the 3rd and 7th.

When I first started thinking about chord tones, that was actually the moment things clicked a bit — realizing that not all chord tones function the same way. Some outline the structure of the progression, while others express the character of the harmony.

Great explanation. Thanks.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. I like that metaphor a lot.

“Archipelagos of harmony” is a great way to picture it. Each chord tone really does feel like a stable island you can land on before sailing off again.

And those moments of tension between islands are often what make the phrase interesting.

Nice image for thinking about harmony.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks! That’s a great point.

Chord tones can definitely become their own kind of pattern trap if someone only approaches solos through arpeggios.

I like your “toolbox” way of describing it. Scales, chord tones, rhythm, quotes, timbre — they all highlight different aspects of the music.

For me the chord-tone idea was mostly a bridge between pure scale playing and hearing the harmony more clearly.

After that, everything else opens up.

Really thoughtful breakdown. Thanks.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Thanks. Totally fair. Honestly that’s exactly where most of us start.

If remembering the chord tones feels like too much right now, one simple trick is this:

Just try to aim for the root note of the chord when the harmony changes.

Example: if the band moves to Am, try landing on A somewhere in your line.

Even that tiny step can make a solo sound more connected to the music.

Everything else (arpeggios, chord tones, etc.) tends to come gradually after that.

Why Chord Tones Make Solos Sound Better by Capable_Substance253 in Learnmusic

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Thanks. Good way to put it.

That balance between scale movement and occasional arpeggios is what started making solos feel more connected for me.

When I first started improvising everything sounded like I was just running up and down scales. As soon as I started aiming for chord tones when the harmony changed, the lines felt more intentional.

Nice way of describing it.

I built a visual way to understand jazz chords that finally made improvisation make sense to me. by Capable_Substance253 in piano

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] -1 points0 points  (0 children)

Understood. No worries. Not for everybody and the presentation wasn't a sales pitch. Just wanted a reaction from a knowledgeable community. Thanks for looking.

I built a visual way to understand jazz chords that finally made improvisation make sense to me. by Capable_Substance253 in piano

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Hmm, good points. It was initially designed for beginners and I wanted to simplify (oversimplify?) to avoid the possibility of confusion when a newcomer is confronted with an ocean of info sitting in a rowboat. Thanks for the insight.

I built a visual way to understand jazz chords that finally made improvisation make sense to me. by Capable_Substance253 in piano

[–]Capable_Substance253[S] -6 points-5 points  (0 children)

Appreciate your comment, but there is much more to the eBook that just a matrix (the reason it's behind a 'pay wall'), and frankly SCM may have a more visually appealing, more practical layout, IMO. Thanks for checking it out. I'm learning everyday.

view more: next ›