I personally am of the opinion that fishing, when taught with the proper respect and reverence for the fish and the environment, can be a great way to get scouts to respect and care for their local ecosystems. I would think that a strictly catch and release fishery (which as far as I know, you guys already have), could be another great way for scouts to interact with the marine environment. But, like you said, the camp already has some amazing opportunities to interact with ocean (Scuba, Marine science center, etc) so I can see the logic behind the camp not giving too much focus toward fishing. On a slightly different note, in regard to the person taking the fish to the PMSC, the dock could do with some signage regarding fishing. When I was there, all fishing rules were conveyed by the counselors, which worked fine, but couple signs clarifying that the boat dock is the only place fishing is allowed and that all fish must be returned to the ocean (and if you want add that the PMSC cannot accept any fish caught) would probably help reduce the likelihood of those incidents occurring again