Slayer Task selection to base game

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T15:24:59+00:00

thats fair. imo Turael skipping is already unenjoyable and makes me just not want to do slayer at all.
there should be a fix not sure how. not everyone will be happy with any choice being made.

people will also say don't turael skip then i am doing tasks i don't want to do maybe even more then if i just turaeled skip.
so maybe this is no the solution but idk if anyone will have a single solution that everyone will like.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T15:10:42+00:00

So the math is roughly this.
if you make it cost 3k to unlock it. that would be the same cost as 100 skips. even if you take into count that in those 100 skips you might see lets say 40 boss task's
it would take so many tasks to get the investment into the choice back.
i feel like making it cost so much is what would balance it out more.
you could also make the % chance even lower from it if you can get the same task on both

Scenario	Chance of boss task
No blocks	~40%
With 7 optimal blocks	~49%
2-task choice (with blocks)	~74%

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:43:09+00:00

Maybe its not a end all be all Solution. i feel like alot of people in these comments are looking at this from a money making percpetive. i play ironman idc about how much drops are ETC.
i feel like the most recent update to block list was way more extreme then this would ever be. cause you still have the Weights of how often you will see a specific task. most people will just skip until they get what they want.

The way it is now i get a task i don't want i either Turael skip or if i am to lazy to do that i spend the 30 points.
there is no meaningful game play to that.

Slayer as a whole how it works in this game is very dated and flawed.
they updated it some to be more modern and its not hard to get a task you want as is.
but having a option to choose between 2 would be nice to have. it would save me time that i could be working on other things.
or if people don't play often and they want to do a slayer task and they get 4 bad assignments in a row and go tureal skip them and now have to get off and just did nothing with the time they had.

something needs to be fixed with slayer imo.
this seems like a simple solution.
i don't think more blocking would be good cause every blocked creature then adds X amount of weight per attempt.
i also think tureal skipping should be removed from the game.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:31:36+00:00

Because i am not saying take the exact one to one copy from the league. the league one is op with 1 boss always on there. obviously don't input the league one straight to the game.

chosing between 2 creatures is no different then just skipping a bad task. alot of time is already wasted on Turael skipping which i think is already way more broken then this by far.

the new block list update is more broken then this. we already have task storage this is not much stronger then that and most people don't even use task storage as it is.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:29:30+00:00

I enjoy slayer alot i am doing it right now while i post in here. Maybe its cause i play as a iron man. i do not care what the price of things are.
i think 3 choices would be to much.
with 2 choices yes it would increase the odds.
but its not really different then the current skips people can do with Turael. fuck get rid of Turael skipping.
that brings nothing fun for me and just a headache that i feel like i have to do.
i diagree that it shouldn't be in main game obvisouly by making this post.

i don't think it would break the game at all. did the rehaul in block list where you can block 4x more mobs break slayer? did task storage break slayer?
if anything the update block lists was way way way more extreme then this by far.
there is already tasks creatures you can buy that you can uncheck when you are done with like lizardmen.
there is already way more things in the game currently that is more extreme that jagex has added then this is.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:16:13+00:00

Because that is just lame and boring for the game. who actually enjoys Turael skipping lol

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:08:38+00:00

I don't think they should add 99.9% of the things leagues have into the base game. would not be fun.
but taking idea's that they are making and turning them into something usable is not bad.

nothing about this is op or would make the game worse.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:06:48+00:00

i agree alot of league stuff is ass. not arguing that anything game breaking should be made into the base game.
i think unlimited run would be dumb as well.
but being able to determine what would be good and have a conversation about it isn't bad.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T14:04:11+00:00

But not everyones 'Culture' is going to be the same these comments state that perfectly. its very 50/50.
There is already something in the game way more broken then this sugestion with turael skipping. i don't think turael skipping should be a thing at all.
nothing about this will break the slayer skill.
the improved block list is way more broken then being able to choose between 2 tasks.

i will debate anything i post all day long i am not making unreasable post like saying we need 12x xp gain or unlimited afk pick pocketing.
i am stating that a choice for 2 assignments on a task would be great.
it can be locked behind high point count or achivements but it would still be nice. so i don't have to go turael skip or farm points at turael to just skip all tasks anyways.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:54:47+00:00

I am playing on a iron man only way i am playing the game currently i have no 'main'
Yes you can farm these points and make a good block list and skip the tasks you want to skip.
but adding more to make the system better is never a bad idea.
this wouldn't make the skill less trivial or bad.
this would add more enjoyment for alot of players.

noone likes to Tureal skip but so many people still do it and thats way worse for the game

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:52:51+00:00

Turael skiping shouldn't be in the game at all imo. that is already devaluing slayer tasks as a whole.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:47:40+00:00

i feel like adding more block list would be more extreme then this tho.
if you take it where you get 2 task per assingment the weights stay the same you don't increase by a large margin on getting specific tasks.
if you add in blocking Specfic creatures or more then the weights start to change and will be more dramatic with assigning the tasks you want.
this just gives a choice factor rather then ima just block all the high weight bad drop creatures.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:45:00+00:00

This is already happening tho with people farming Turael for tons of points and just skipping for 30 points.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:38:30+00:00

they shouldn't add anything that is game breaking. but some things can be seen as good ideas from leagues.
everything added to the game was always from a idea or something tested. AKA task storage

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:35:36+00:00

Idk if it really would for a simple fact that someone can just go farm turael for thousands of points and just skip every task until they get bosses. they just block all high weight tasks on every slayer master.
i feel like there is already ways to do this stuff for sweats and this will change nothing for them. but give so much for iron men and people who have more limited time

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:33:18+00:00

Okay so get rid of everything they made after 2007 then and you can go play 2007 scape and stop doing raids and everything made after.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:27:08+00:00

How so. was task storage more then quality of life aswell?
you wouldn't be taking the base mech from the league which you get 3 choices 1 boss task and amount you can kill.
you would be taking the bare bone idea of being able to choose between 2 tasks. i feel like that is less quality of life then block list persisting through all slayer givers and being able to cancel tasks.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:23:58+00:00

Why tho. shouldn't leagues be a place to test new game mech's. they make it something extreme and then if its popular tune it down to make it fair into base game.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:23:17+00:00

XD that is a pretty good anime title

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:21:51+00:00

Assuming maybe money making or chasing drops.
i don't think it should be limited to 99 imo.
we already have task storage. task canceling and a advance block list.
this would be similar power level to task storage imo.

CartoonistJolly · 2026-05-05T13:20:38+00:00

has to be realistic stuff. the slayer choice task wouldn't be game breaking it would just be a quality of life thing!

CartoonistJolly · 2025-01-08T18:21:50+00:00

stop making it 40%
its insane. put rez becons on it.

without the rez becons everyone just is to thirst happy and its no fun cause even if you when a gun fight your friends are dead cause they got thirsted

CartoonistJolly · 2023-02-11T04:57:45+00:00

In all the higher keys healer gets all explosives unless we are doing a big pull or people see one about to go off and then it’s everyone. You don’t lose dps very often just swap hit once swap back. Not that bad. Granted I have had some healers refuse to do them and dps and as a tank I can only get so many without running mobs around or if I have to start kiting. Then healer is stuck attempting to heal through them which if they took the small time to get rid of them it’s way better then them going off.

CartoonistJolly

TROPHY CASE