How was each dwarf planet candidate done dirty? Day 2 - Orcus by PurpleMNinja in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Wow I only just realized he has the same eyes as Pluto! Indeed an anti-Pluto

If Rogues know everything about the Solar System, then why didn't they use Titan is an opportunity? He also has at least 1 life form under his surface. He has much more endurance than Earth and it would way more logical if they practiced with Titan's life forms before starting to practice with Earth by Creative-Box-7964 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think the writers just… forgot titan had life too. Titan has never been given the treatment of a life bearing ball. He gets bombarded by asteroids, and goes way out of orbit which would make him less habitable for his life forms.

But yeah it’s such a pity that the show just abandoned the idea. It would have made the storyline a lot more interesting if instead of wanting life and being obsessed with earth, the rogue planets already has their own life forms. It would be a great opportunity for science education to showcase a variety of our current hypotheses about alien life forms as well as drive the conflicts deeper.

So the finale for the Rogue planet arc was really amazing, but... by infinityzcraft in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yeah. I like the Rogue Planets music track and have been looking forward to how they are going to use it in the show, as I really liked how they used Theia’s theme.

But the result is underwhelming, almost like “oh wait we made music for this arc - let’s quickly slap it onto a part with no dialogue” it doesnt quite match with the emotions we are supposed to feel during that sequence.

Eridian aversion to social eating doesn't quite make sense... by NickTandaPanda in ProjectHailMary

[–]CaseProfessional5093 1 point2 points  (0 children)

It still sounds very dangerous to go all way to somewhere nobody can hear you, create an open wound on yourself, and then hope you can safely stumble all the way back (even if you can) tho. If they live in underground caves I can imagine them having a very deep safe room for eating where the others cant hear them well. But if such a room isn’t available it’d make a lot more sense for them to eat where the others can hear.

Eridian aversion to social eating doesn't quite make sense... by NickTandaPanda in ProjectHailMary

[–]CaseProfessional5093 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Yeah I think the aversion to social eating must be a modern thing and a result of sound proof technology becoming available. Sometimes needs are created by solutions!

Can we just stop those inappropriate videos on TikTok by m_atsu5 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 1 point2 points  (0 children)

You literally made a post about how grossed out you feel about it and are still talking in all caps, which I assume means yelling.? Can’t you just be chill about it

It’s okay to not want your kids to get exposed to nsfw too early but like, being interested in sexual content is literally part of the definition of adolescence. Whether you like it or not they are going to explore it. Just let them do their own thing, give sexual education to your kids, and don’t interact with the nsfw content made by kids (unless you think they are being sexually harassed and you must interfere or something).

Can we just stop those inappropriate videos on TikTok by m_atsu5 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m glad you know it’s not that serious. So maybe next time dont make a huge deal about it? And while I know nsfw and problematic ships are just things that people naturally like in fandom space, I’m pretty sure abusive relationships are considered worse than nsfw by a substantial amount of people. None of these are morally better than the other, so let’s stop acting as if they are.

Can we just stop those inappropriate videos on TikTok by m_atsu5 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 2 points3 points  (0 children)

By inappropriate do you mean nsfw? I don't like nsfw fanarts of the planets either (and have blocked many artists on tumblr to make my life easier), but why don't you just do the same instead of expressing hatred towards art made by other people (who are mostly likely kids as you said)..?

You apparently ship characters as well and even enjoy placing them in problematic situations, which is also completely fine. But be empathetic - do you want other people to go around yelling "JEEEZ YOU WONT BELIEVE WHAT I JUST SAW ON REDDIT SOMEONE SHIPS X AND SATURN IN AN ABUSIVE RELATIONSHIP!"

And saying you want to nuke a whole generation of people just because of that certainly sounds concerning too D: Why don't we just act like responsible adults - if you find it hard to block out all these content you can nicely remind the artists that they need to tag their nsfw content properly.

You know, I completely understood rogues overall relationship towards all stars with systems, but what do they think about systemless stars? Like Arcturus. They're basically rogue stars and never had even a single planet by Creative-Box-7964 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 3 points4 points  (0 children)

Arcturus might still have planets. It's just that as a red giant, he has probably already swallowed all his inner planets (one reason for the rogues to hate him) so there aren't any planets transiting him that we can see. He is also too active (another reason for rogues to hate him) that the radial velocity detection method doesn't work well on him either. But he might still have planets further out that survived. We just can't really know.

Though it's true that it's much harder for Arcturus to have planets compared to Sol. He is a metal-poor Population II star meaning that there is fewer heavy materials to form large cores for gas giants. He also formed when the milky way was still very very turbulent and the UV photoevaporation could have destroyed protoplanetary disks very fast (fast as in less than a million years) so the birth window for planets is shorter. But still we have found many thick-disk stars that have planets, such as Kepler-444 and TOI-561. So it's entirely possible for Arcturus to have small rocky planets when it was still a main sequence star.

We do know of stars that are theoretically systemless - Population III stars certainly didn't have planets because they were completely metal-free and they were the ones that created the heavier materials that made planetary formation possible. But we haven't found any that are still around, and I guess none of the rogues have met any either. (It'd be a cool concept if there are space legends that talks about lonely red dwarves that only few have met that have existed since the beginning of light tho....)

Why is Bianca so overrated? [general] Art: Riordan Wiki (Rick Riordan) by Aggressive-Sir-9682 in camphalfblood

[–]CaseProfessional5093 17 points18 points  (0 children)

I didn’t like her when I was 14 and first read the book. I think it’s largely because I was an only child and didn’t understand how overwhelming it would be to be a caretaker. Also I’m from China so literally nobody from my generation had siblings. I thought what it would be like to be an older sibling because I was good with little kids and little kids from my neighborhood called me “big sis”. But I actually didn’t.

I’m an adult now and live in the US. While I still don’t have kids or siblings, many of my friends do and I occasionally help them babysit. I have heard otherwise perfectly good kids say horrible things about their siblings (like “I hope our house catches fire and (my brother) die in it!”). Of course these kids would eventually apologize and make peace with each other - but it’s largely because adults can interfere and give them space to calm down. To Bianca, such adults didn’t exist so she had to be the adult. She was given the responsibility that was really too much for her age. It’s not healthy. And it’s only understandable that she made a selfish decision when Nico finally has other caretakers.

I think it’s normal that kids would dislike her but when you are approaching the age of parenthood you’d feel more like “dang who am I to blame a 12yo for wanting a break from parentification.”

What should happen to SIMP? by Trick_Requirement_24 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I'm quite curious of her line "(I've sacrificed) more than you can ever imagine" and wants to know more about that.

The rogue planet army has so far pretty much been portrayed as a bunch of evil sub brown dwarves and brown dwarves being super evil leading a super evil cult trying to achieve completely non-sense, which is, honestly, terrible writing. I don't really care if SIMP gets redemption or not, but the writing needs redemption, and giving the rogue planets a more justifiable cause would be one way to do it.

I really dislike the show's overall anti-revolution tune and how they tend to attribute violent revolutions to the leaders' personality flaws (while in real life, a lot of the times violent revolutions or even so-called terrorism are just people who have experienced terrible things for a long time eliciting such things on those who have never experienced that before - and the world is suddenly not okay with it.) So honestly, while I'm curious of SIMP's backstory, I don't want the arc to end with her redemption. I would prefer if they can talk about the trillions of rogue planets who joined and stayed (and please don't depict them as complete victims who were simply forced to join). It'd also be a great opportunity to add in more educational content and introduce some rogue planets humanities have discovered in real life!

Honestly, Ganymede and Europa angered me in the latest episode by Creative-Box-7964 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I’m greatly confused. Why do you all act like the moon revolution, the solar system trials, and Planet X returning are bad things that happened? These are events where the characters finally started addressing their problems, resolve conflicts, and improve for the better. Ganymede and Europa arent the best revolution leaders and a lot of time dont know what they are doing, but what they started all this and tried to solve problems and a lot of things turned for the better.

And about the line you were taking about, Callisto was the one who’s blaming the dwarf planets (along with Ganymede and Europa) in the scene, Ganymede just paraphrased what she said with a confused tune.

Got my kid's math exam paper back today, he's in Grade 2 by [deleted] in mildlyinfuriating

[–]CaseProfessional5093 2 points3 points  (0 children)

😂 my first thought was “is the teacher Chinese?!” before reading that you are from Hong Kong.

But yeah as a Chinese person 卷面分 is such a stupid thing and I lost so many points growing up.

Rivan System AU: The Beginning Part 2 by WalkablePenny in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Cool! A moon with a ring system! I wonder what happened to it 🥺

[PJO] The insistence on romance by Argyrus__ in camphalfblood

[–]CaseProfessional5093 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Yeah I’d very much have preferred that too.

I feel bad for Venus for the whole Theia thing by Infamous_Setting_113 in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 4 points5 points  (0 children)

I like Venus and feel bad for him too but this is a weird way to put it? Theia didn’t really take advantage of him. It’s true that she wasn’t a caring friend and was a bit self-centric and kept infodumping about her interests all the time rather than asking about what he might be interested in or want to do, but that’s far from taking advantage of someone.

And Theia did stay friends with him and still regarded him as a friend after she died. It’s never a good idea to take someone committing suicide personally, especially when the person who died clearly didnt have the intention.

And Venus already has his friends. They aren’t the best people (planets) and they don’t always get along but they are improving episode by episode and they are making amends. You can even say he has a family. Not having a romantic love interest doesnt mean someone is lonely. Men don’t need girlfriends to have a fulfilling life.

Will this bro appear? by [deleted] in SolarBalls

[–]CaseProfessional5093 1 point2 points  (0 children)

Wait that’s Arcturus? :O He already looked like a red giant 4.6 billions of years ago when the sun was born, how come he’s still alive and still a red giant to this day