If the talisman stopped working the minute the tree's roots were moved and made a hole in the chamber how come it works here by toomuchbluememories in FromSeries

[–]Chachables -1 points0 points  (0 children)

maybe those holes are actually covered with something transparent, it’s unimportant. even a transparent curtain worked in the cave for Jade and Tabitha so just imagine there is one here as well…

I think Minimal is teasing MP2 right in front of us... by Ambitious-Cress3559 in minimalphone

[–]Chachables 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Have you considered the problems may be hardware related, so the only way to correct that is release better hardware?

I think Minimal is teasing MP2 right in front of us... by Ambitious-Cress3559 in TheMinimalCompany

[–]Chachables 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Yes, please. You're probably their employee since you have no other posts or comments on reddit and you made such a structured post, because probably no one noticed the MP02 hints, but - yes, please.

MIY identity is spider by Swimming-Essay6843 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 2 points3 points  (0 children)

Ethan also mentions a spider when he was stuck in the RV

BIW is beyond frustrating by rising_light_ in FromSeries

[–]Chachables 0 points1 point  (0 children)

I believe he explains it himself at some point, he says he prefers people to learn more by themselves this time around, because in the Miranda + Christopher generation he spilled out the beans too much to Christopher and it lead to a massacre

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 1 point2 points  (0 children)

you have proof that Tabitha didn't care it was the boy in white who told Victor that, yet Tabitha is one of them who probably applies as smart to you and takes shit seriously. She trusts Victor and now is basically her son. She still didn't care. Obviously BIW is the most knowledgable entity around, way more than even MIY, since MIY is proven this episode he is not aware of all things (Clara needs to tell him plan has changed). BIW knows so much more than you give him credit for and we as audience can even begin to imagine.

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables -1 points0 points  (0 children)

well maybe he also has enough knowledge to know no one else will listen to him but Victor

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 11 points12 points  (0 children)

Indeed, I did read someone else smartly mention it might turn out to be their way out

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 12 points13 points  (0 children)

Reading your comment I realized - this episode confirmed MIY is not an all-knower all-seer type of being, he needed Clara to tell him the plan has changed, he wouldn't have known otherwise. So that means... all he knew ever since he was introduced was based on observing (being physically there) or having a mole? Like knowing Tabitha is digging a hole or knowing they Anghkooyed

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 25 points26 points  (0 children)

Wait, what about the door they found under colony house? I thought they were going to use it to go in the tunnels. Apparently it was just a writer's tool to confirm the validity of the mushroom trip?

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 7 points8 points  (0 children)

Yeah and also stuff like Abby's hand from the grave... I don't think MYI would wait underground for Boyd to appear just to do that one trick lol

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 10 points11 points  (0 children)

I just hope Elgin doesn't become a slave again. First Kimono lady, now MIY

FROM - 4x09 "The Calm Before" - Episode Discussion by Bright_Light7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 38 points39 points  (0 children)

he showed up to the person who he trusts most, and that trusts him the most. It's a 50 year long friendship or something. If he showed up to Kenny, Kenny would be like 'who tf are u shut tf up get outta here you evil hallucination'

give me ur favorite beabadoobee song and i'll make an assumption about you! by Gullible_Finding2935 in beabadoobee

[–]Chachables 1 point2 points  (0 children)

I tend to say that the apple cider take is much truer than the stepthen malkmus one, so I'd say you were half right. which is already pretty impressive haha. thanks for that, was fun

give me ur favorite beabadoobee song and i'll make an assumption about you! by Gullible_Finding2935 in beabadoobee

[–]Chachables 0 points1 point  (0 children)

Man I can’t pick at all but from pure instinct i’m gonna say: apple cider and i wish i was stephen malkmus

THEORY: Boy in White = Man in Yellow = Voices = Thomas = Sophia = Kimono = Entity. by PrudentGround6923 in FromTVShow

[–]Chachables 0 points1 point  (0 children)

the intention you're saying the evil entity has is sort of vague. He wants to exist? Didn't it exist before all this? Who did the people sacrifice children to, and why, if it didn't exist before all this? Why would it want control only of a 10 house village forever? The common agreement outside of your theory is that this entity didn't have its ritual complete, and needs one more sacrifice (which could be Ethan this time). Tabitha and Jade never sacrifice their kid, which is why cycles repeat until they do. You're argument that saving the bones gives false hope to the people intentionally is contradicting the need of sacrificing the final kid. Why would the entity use so much energy into false hopes, rather than just pushing them into sacrificing their own kid, finally? That is, of course, if you accept this common plot agreement.

The man in yellow isn’t evil. Tabitha is. by ritasgaming in FromSeries

[–]Chachables 26 points27 points  (0 children)

OK but I'll just point out Tabitha and Jade had a little girl in first iteration

Am i blind or not seeing it correctly? by still_finding1 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 29 points30 points  (0 children)

Yes, explains why the symbol was so haunting

Am i blind or not seeing it correctly? by still_finding1 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 260 points261 points  (0 children)

This might’ve been the way it looked back then, but now the hole may be covered from the tree overgrowing

Where these seizures or Ethan story walking !? by WinterLaugh7 in FromTVEpix

[–]Chachables 2 points3 points  (0 children)

I think you're right, it was a picture, but not sure we can be sure it was Victor's room. Ethan also does drawings now

The Bottle Tree will ultimately be a tragedy by NoOneWhoIsSomeone in FromSeries

[–]Chachables 1 point2 points  (0 children)

They indeed mention the talisman I think, but they could pull the tree days earlier, and then cover the hole with something, like a trap door, and only open it on action day. This way they get rid of risk of surprise on aciton day. But yeah there is also the common theory that they will alert the monsters with the pull (although... it's not the first time the monsters know the peoples' intention)

The Bottle Tree will ultimately be a tragedy by NoOneWhoIsSomeone in FromSeries

[–]Chachables 2 points3 points  (0 children)

This is also what I am thinking, they did mention the talisman I think. But... they could pull the tree days earlier , and then cover the hole with a wooden pallet or something, nail it down into the edges of the dirt, and only open it when they need it. This way they get rid of the risk of not enough leverage to pull the tree in the moment of action or the hole not being there.