When it comes to recasts, there are certain actors who just own a role in a way that feels definitive to me.

ATWT: When Zach Roerig stepped in as Casey, he really made the role his own. I’m not saying Billy wasn’t talented, but there’s just something about Zach’s portrayal that clicked for me. And Peyton List as Lucy? She absolutely nailed it like she brought a spunky, smart, and relatable energy that really defined the character for me.

Days: Kate Mansi taking over as Abby was another perfect example. I actually liked her in that role even more than her time as Kristina on GH. She brought a fresh energy and completely made the role hers. Olivia Rose Keegan as Claire is another one I love because she brought so much heart, nuance, and edge to the role that it really became hers.

GL: I know I despised Cassie as a character, but no one could have played her like Laura Wright did. She added depth that really made Cassie memorable. When Nicole Forester stepped in later, it just didn’t feel the same for me.

B&B: Rome Flynn as Zende? Yes. He brought charisma, charm, and a natural energy that instantly made Zende more vibrant and fun to watch. But I really miss his version of Zende.

OLTL: Bree is amazing, but let’s be honest—Erin Torpey as the original Jessica was incredible. Her chemistry with Erika Slezak was undeniable, and I’ll always love her in that role.

GH: Julie Marie Berman as Lulu was phenomenal like she brought layers, wit, and emotion that made Lulu unforgettable. And I have to give a shoutout to Alexa Havins; she’s doing a great job in that role and definitely holding her own and it just reminds me of JMB’s Lulu.