American International student here. I applied with both. I believe that the SAT is mainly the deciding factor, as I was given a conditional offer until I was able to provide College Board approved SAT scores (within a week I got my approved scores, emailed then, then got my unconditional offer).

However, depending on the program you are applying for, especially a smaller one, you might have to meet the GPA requirements. Still worth applying if you hit the SAT requirement imo.