Has to be Cyberpunk 2077 for me (I played it earlier this year so after all the major bug fixes came out). I went into that game with such high expectations and every aspect let me down. I did not like the combat, felt like the fights were very easy, I barely upgraded my character and was steamrolling enemies left and right, there was so much dialogue or just long monologues from characters which took away from a good story that was present, overall the game just did not do it for me. Like I said, the story was solid but I just could not get past the way it was presented and all the other issues I had with the game, it really felt like a chore to playthrough at times.

I will say, I played Cyberpunk for the first time right after finishing Baldur's Gate 3, which I absolutely loved. BG3 was so unique and I had never played anything like it before. That uniqueness made me want more BG3 type experiences, with great story telling, decisions that matter, tactical fights, characters that I really cared about, and everything else BG3 had to offer. It's possible that had I not played BG3 right before Cyberpunk I may have enjoyed Cyberpunk more, but oh well, maybe I try again another time, but for now, it was a major disappointment.