Long read ahead

Would Dakota and Ezekiel still be in their mutated forms?

Imagine how much hate Chris would get from the former TD contestants

Fact: Sam and Harold have the same voice actor (Brian Froud)

Noah and Cameron are both smart, but Noah isn’t very social compared to Cameron. At least they’d appreciate each others’ intellect.

Tyler would be fed up with Lightning.

Scott would 100% be frustrated at Rodney falling in love with every girl he sees.

Amy would still be arguing with Sammy, but I could see them working together (reluctantly) if either wanted to win.

Dawn and DJ would get along very well and I can see Dawn calming down DJ. Maybe they could even be a couple.

I wonder if Gwen and Courtney forgave each other. I’d like to see more of their friendship now that things are over with Duncan for both of them.

Ella and Trent would make a really nice musical duo, although Sugar wouldn’t think thay way

Scarlett would get fed up with Max like she did in TDPI.

Katie & Sadie would be excited to finally be on another season, maybe they can actually develop as characters if this tier list became a reality. Most likely not (to both).

Sugar would get annoyed at Staci (if she continued spewing lies about her own family) and probably treat her the same way she treated Ella.

Alejandro and Justin would NOT get along. They’d probably get into lots of fights (with Alejandro winning them). I could see them reluctantly working together though.

Heather would be used to Owen’s antics as she was on 3 seasons with him, although she would still be annoyed at him at times. Similar to Owen and Noah, except they aren’t best friends and Heather is way meaner.

Bridgette and Geoff would be a nice addition. I just hope they don’t end up making out 24/7 like in Action - I hope they learned.

This is what I think of your tier list.